The New York Appellate Division has upheld a lower court's ruling in a family dispute involving the Star Growers Farm, affirming the division of land and financial responsibilities among the brothers involved. The decision, made on November 20, 2026, affects Leo D. Starowitz, Jr. and his brothers, who co-own the farm and its operations. The ruling clarifies their obligations and rights regarding land ownership and profit sharing as they navigate the complexities of their family business.

The case, known as Starowitz v. Star Growers Farm, LLC, was filed under docket number 675 CA 25-00477. The dispute arose after disagreements among the brothers about how to manage the farm and its assets. This ruling is significant as it addresses the enforceability of a settlement agreement made in court and the interpretation of its terms.

In this case, Leo D. Starowitz, Jr. (the plaintiff) and his brothers, Andrew M. Starowitz, Frank L. Starowitz, and John F. Starowitz (the defendants), each hold a one-quarter interest in the entities that operate Star Growers Farm, LLC, Star Growers Land, LLC, and Star Growers, Inc. The brothers had previously run the farm together, but disputes led to Leo initiating legal action seeking judicial dissolution of the entities. The matter was resolved through a settlement agreement in November 2023, but disagreements about its interpretation prompted further legal action.

The underlying conflict involved the distribution of land and financial responsibilities following the settlement agreement. The brothers had agreed to transfer certain real estate and equipment as part of their settlement, but disputes arose regarding the interpretation of the terms, leading to motions from both sides to enforce their understanding of the agreement.

The Appellate Division ruled on the appeal from an order issued by the Supreme Court in Genesee County on March 4, 2025. The court affirmed the lower court's decision to grant Leo 30 acres of land as outlined in the settlement agreement and ruled that he would be responsible for 25% of the farm's operating expenses until the settlement was finalized. The court's ruling emphasized that the settlement agreement, made in open court, was enforceable as a contract.

According to the court, "[a]n oral stipulation of settlement that is made in open court and stenographically recorded is enforceable as a contract and is governed by general contract principles for its interpretation and effect." The judges involved in the ruling included Montour, Ogden, Greenwood, Nowak, and Skinner.

The court determined that Leo's claim that he should not be responsible for operational expenses was unfounded. The ruling stated that the settlement agreement contained a condition precedent, meaning that Leo remained a one-quarter owner of the farm business until the property transfer was completed. Thus, he was still liable for his share of expenses and entitled to his share of profits during that period.

The court also clarified the terms regarding the land. Leo was entitled to 30 acres as specified in the settlement, along with potential solar income payments from that land and an additional 20 acres if solar panels were installed. The court rejected Leo's argument that he should receive more land to account for municipal setback requirements, stating that the settlement agreement clearly defined the land to be transferred.

In its ruling, the court noted that the term "tillable" was ambiguous and subject to interpretation. However, it found that the extrinsic evidence supported the conclusion that the hidden field on the property was non-tillable and therefore not included in the land Leo was entitled to receive. The court emphasized that Leo's unilateral actions to cultivate the hidden field after the settlement did not change the original intent of the parties.

The implications of this ruling extend beyond the immediate dispute among the brothers. It reinforces the importance of clear and unambiguous language in settlement agreements and highlights how courts interpret such agreements based on the parties' intentions at the time of execution. This case serves as a reminder for individuals and businesses to ensure that their agreements are explicitly defined to avoid future disputes.

Moving forward, the ruling sets a precedent for how similar disputes may be handled in New York courts, particularly regarding family-owned businesses and the enforceability of oral settlement agreements. It underscores the necessity for parties to understand their obligations and rights under such agreements, especially in the context of shared ownership and operational responsibilities.

As for the future of this case, it remains to be seen whether Leo will seek to appeal the Appellate Division's decision. The court did not specify any further related cases pending, but the ruling may influence how similar disputes are resolved in the future.