The California Court of Appeal has upheld a domestic violence restraining order (DVRO) protecting B.O. (the father) and his two children from V.C. (the mother). The court ruled that the mother had committed acts of domestic abuse and that the restraining order was necessary for the safety of the father and children. This decision is significant as it reinforces the importance of protecting children in domestic violence situations.
The case, B.O. v. V.C., was filed under docket number D087187. The court's ruling came after a series of events that highlighted the mother's troubling behavior and the father's concerns for his safety and that of their children.
Background
B.O. and V.C. were never married but share two children, born in 2016 and 2019. They lived together in San Diego until February 2022, when V.C. took the children to Las Vegas without B.O.'s knowledge or consent. This led to a three-month period of no contact between the father and children. B.O. subsequently filed for a parentage action and a DVRO against V.C., citing her abusive behavior during their relationship.
In August 2023, the family court issued a two-year DVRO against V.C., determining that she had committed acts of domestic abuse against B.O. The court found that V.C. had used the children to manipulate B.O. and had berated him in front of them. Along with the DVRO, the court granted B.O. sole legal and physical custody of the children and required V.C. to attend a batterer prevention program.
Following the issuance of the DVRO, V.C. attempted to file her own restraining order against B.O. but was unsuccessful. The court denied her request, and she later appealed the decision. In October 2023, the family court denied her renewed request for a restraining order, leading to further legal disputes between the two parties.
The Ruling
On November 20, 2026, the California Court of Appeal affirmed the family court's decision to renew the DVRO for an additional five years. The court ruled that the evidence presented clearly indicated that V.C. posed a continuing threat to B.O. and the children. The court stated, "[T]he evidence I have before me is pretty clear based upon the declarations."
The court found that V.C. had engaged in behavior that emotionally abused the children and showed a lack of insight into how her actions affected them. The ruling also included modifications to V.C.'s visitation rights, reducing her access to the children and requiring that all interactions be supervised.
Throughout the proceedings, V.C. represented herself in court, as did B.O. The judge's decision was based on substantial evidence, including video recordings of V.C.'s unsupervised interactions with the children and her communications with B.O. that violated court orders.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for domestic violence cases in California. It underscores the court's commitment to ensuring the safety of children in situations where domestic violence is present. The decision also reinforces the importance of compliance with court orders regarding visitation and communication.
By including the children as protected parties in the DVRO, the court acknowledged the potential harm that could arise from V.C.'s behavior. This ruling sets a precedent for similar cases, emphasizing that the courts will take necessary actions to protect children from emotional and physical harm.
What's Next
V.C. may seek to appeal the court's decision, although the court filing did not indicate any pending related cases. The outcome of this case may influence future domestic violence proceedings, particularly regarding the treatment of children in such disputes.
Read Next
Kentucky Court Reverses Summary Judgment in Civil Case
California Court of Appeal rules on parental rights case
Court rules on service issues in Alsanabani v. Spear Group
Alaska Supreme Court rules on child support and property division
Alaska Supreme Court Rules on Indian Custodianship Rights
Court affirms divorce decree and contempt ruling in Herdler case










