The Hawaii Intermediate Court of Appeals has affirmed a lower court's ruling in the case of Adam O. Mays versus Pacific Permanente Group LLC and Hawaii Permanente Medical Group, Inc. This decision, filed on November 20, 2026, centers around Mays' claims of breach of employment contract and violation of the Hawaii Whistleblowers' Protection Act (HWPA). The court's ruling impacts Mays and the two medical groups involved, setting a precedent for similar employment disputes in Hawaii.

Adam O. Mays, a physician extender, alleged that his employers breached his contract and retaliated against him for whistleblowing. The Circuit Court of the Second Circuit had previously granted summary judgment in favor of Pacific Permanente and Hawaii Permanente, leading Mays to appeal the decision. The court's ruling is significant as it clarifies the boundaries of employment contracts and whistleblower protections in the state.

Mays entered into a Practitioner Employment Agreement with Pacific Permanente in August 2020, which outlined his responsibilities and the terms of his employment. His role involved providing medical services at the Maui Memorial Medical Center and other locations. However, tensions arose when Mays sought to change his work schedule to four ten-hour days, which his supervisors rejected, insisting he work five days a week as a full-time employee.

After a series of meetings with his supervisors, Mays sent an email on January 1, 2021, expressing concerns about his work environment and the ultimatum he faced regarding his schedule. He described feeling undermined and threatened by the leadership at Pacific Permanente. Mays subsequently took an unofficial leave of absence, which he argued was a justified response to the hostile work environment. However, he later admitted that this leave was unauthorized, leading to his termination.

The case reached the Intermediate Court of Appeals after Mays appealed the lower court's decision, which had ruled in favor of his employers on both the breach of contract and HWPA claims. The court found that Mays had indeed breached his employment contract by taking an unauthorized leave. The court stated, "Having breached the Agreement himself, he cannot maintain a claim for breach of contract against Pacific Permanente."

Furthermore, the court ruled that Mays did not qualify as a protected whistleblower under the HWPA. The evidence presented did not support his claims that he reported any violations of law or regulations as required by the statute. The court noted that Mays's email primarily expressed dissatisfaction with his work conditions rather than reporting any legal violations.

The court concluded, "No reasonable jury could interpret the email as a 'report' of 'a violation or a suspected violation of . . . [a] law, rule, ordinance, or regulation.'" This ruling reinforces the importance of clearly demonstrating protected whistleblower activity to qualify for protections under the HWPA.

In addition to affirming the lower court's ruling on Mays' claims, the Intermediate Court of Appeals also addressed the issue of attorney fees. The lower court had denied Pacific Permanente and Hawaii Permanente's request for attorney fees, but the appeals court found that they were entitled to recover these costs. The court stated that Mays's claims were intertwined, and thus the employers could seek attorney fees under Hawaii Revised Statutes § 607-14.

The ruling has implications for future employment disputes in Hawaii, particularly regarding the standards for whistleblower claims and the enforcement of employment contracts. It highlights the necessity for employees to provide clear evidence when claiming whistleblower protections and underscores the importance of adhering to contractual obligations.

Looking ahead, the case may have further developments as the circuit court will determine the specific amount of attorney fees owed to Pacific Permanente and Hawaii Permanente. Mays's options for appeal appear limited, as the Intermediate Court of Appeals has upheld the lower court's decision on both claims.