The Hawaii Intermediate Court of Appeals ruled that Jonathan Brian Thomas cannot seal records related to a protective order he was involved with. This decision affects Thomas and the legal handling of protective order records in Hawaii.

On November 19, 2026, the court issued a summary disposition order affirming the lower court's decision from April 10, 2025. The ruling clarifies the legal standards for sealing records of protective orders, particularly distinguishing between different types of protective orders.

The case began when Peter Giles petitioned for a temporary restraining order against Thomas in 2006. Giles claimed that Thomas had entered a staff meeting uninvited and made threatening comments. However, the district court denied Giles' request, stating there was not enough evidence to support the claim of harassment.

Almost two decades later, Thomas filed a Petition to Seal and Restrict Records of the Temporary Protective Order. He argued that the denial of his request to keep the protective order petition private violated Hawaii Revised Statutes (HRS) § 586-5.5(c). This statute allows for sealing records in cases involving family and household members.

The court noted that while HRS § 586-5.5 governs protective orders related to family abuse, Giles' original petition was filed under HRS § 604-10.5, which addresses harassment claims against any person. The court emphasized that the two statutes are distinct and that HRS § 604-10.5 does not include provisions for sealing records based on a respondent's request.

The court stated, "The district court did not err by denying Thomas' Petition to Seal." This statement underscores the court's position that the legal framework governing protective orders in cases of harassment does not allow for the same sealing provisions as those for family-related cases.

The ruling has implications for individuals seeking to seal protective order records in Hawaii. It clarifies that the ability to seal such records is limited to specific circumstances outlined in the relevant statutes. This decision may discourage similar requests from respondents in harassment cases who might seek to shield their records from public view.

Moving forward, this ruling sets a precedent for how courts in Hawaii will handle requests to seal records related to protective orders. It reinforces the importance of the statutory distinctions between different types of protective orders and the specific legal criteria that must be met to justify sealing records.

As for what’s next, it is unclear if Thomas plans to appeal the ruling. The court filing did not indicate any pending related cases or further actions from either party. However, the decision may prompt other individuals in similar situations to reconsider their requests to seal protective order records in light of this ruling.