The Hawaii Intermediate Court of Appeals has upheld a lower court's decision to grant an injunction against harassment in the case of Hochman v. Boyd, docket number CAAP-25-0000096. The ruling, issued on November 19, 2026, affects Heather Boyd, who appealed the decision made by the District Court of the First Circuit in favor of Venice Hochman. This case highlights the complexities of harassment claims and the challenges faced by self-represented litigants in navigating the legal system.
In this case, Venice Hochman, the petitioner-appellee, sought legal protection against Heather Boyd, the respondent-appellant, after Boyd allegedly sent numerous distressing emails regarding her termination from the IRS. The court's decision to uphold the injunction is significant as it reinforces the authority of district courts to address harassment claims and the standards for evidence in such cases.
Background
The parties involved in this case are Venice Hochman and Heather Boyd. Hochman is an employee of the IRS and a union steward, while Boyd was previously employed by the IRS as a Tax Compliance Officer until her termination in 2014 due to violations of a last-chance agreement. The dispute arose when Boyd began sending a series of emails to Hochman in October 2024, which Hochman claimed were harassing and repetitive in nature.
After receiving these emails, Hochman filed a petition for an injunction against harassment in the District Court of the First Circuit. The court granted the injunction on February 14, 2025, for a period of one year. Boyd, acting as her own attorney, appealed the decision, arguing that the district court lacked jurisdiction and that the emails did not cause distress.
The Ruling
The Hawaii Intermediate Court of Appeals, led by Chief Judge Karen T. Nakasone and Associate Judges Keith K. Hiraoka and Sonja M.P. McCullen, reviewed the case and affirmed the lower court's ruling. The court noted that Boyd's appeal raised several arguments, including a challenge to the district court's jurisdiction and claims that the emails served a legitimate purpose.
The court stated, "Hochman's petition was not filed pursuant to any federal authority. Accordingly, the district court had jurisdiction over Hochman's petition." This ruling clarifies that state courts can handle harassment cases involving federal employees when the claims are based on state law.
Additionally, the court addressed Boyd's argument regarding the lack of distress caused by the emails, stating, "this court does not pass upon the credibility of witnesses." The court emphasized that without a transcript of the original proceedings, they could not review the credibility of the claims made by either party.
Impact
The court's decision to uphold the injunction against harassment has broader implications for self-represented litigants in Hawaii. It underscores the importance of adhering to procedural rules in appellate cases, as Boyd's appeal was hampered by her failure to comply with the Hawaii Rules of Appellate Procedure. The court noted that Boyd's opening brief lacked citations to the record or relevant legal authorities, which is crucial for a successful appeal.
This ruling reinforces the district court's ability to issue injunctions against harassment and sets a precedent for future cases involving similar claims. It highlights the necessity for individuals to present their arguments clearly and within the framework of established legal procedures, particularly when representing themselves.
What's Next
Details were not available in the court filing regarding whether Boyd plans to appeal this decision further. Given the nature of the case and the ruling, it is possible that Boyd may seek further legal recourse, but any future actions would need to comply with the appropriate legal standards and procedures.
Read Next
Hawaii Court Affirms Denial to Seal Protective Order Records
Mississippi Supreme Court Reverses City Attorney Termination
Mississippi Supreme Court clarifies healthcare surrogate law
California Court denies mother's petition for reunification
California Court dismisses appeal in Mohaddess v. Patel case
Tax Court Rules on Income Tax Dispute for Georgia Couple










