The California Court of Appeal recently affirmed a lower court's ruling in a property dispute involving Linda Carrillo and Raymond Kearney. The case centers on claims regarding the enforcement of covenants, conditions, and restrictions (CC&Rs) related to Carrillo's home. The decision is significant as it clarifies how anti-SLAPP motions are applied in property disputes.
The dispute began when Carrillo purchased her home from Kearney in 2002. The sale included a grant deed that contained specific CC&Rs. Over the years, tensions arose between the two neighbors, particularly regarding improvements Carrillo wanted to make to her property. In 2025, Kearney filed a lawsuit against Carrillo, alleging that she violated the CC&Rs by undertaking construction work in her backyard.
In response, Carrillo filed a cross-complaint against Kearney, claiming breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing, among other allegations. Kearney then filed a special motion to strike Carrillo's cross-claim, arguing that it was based on his right to petition the court to enforce the CC&Rs. This motion was made under California's anti-SLAPP statute, which is designed to prevent strategic lawsuits against public participation.
The case reached the California Court of Appeal after Kearney's motion was denied by the trial court. The court found that Carrillo's implied covenant cross-claim did not arise solely from Kearney's initiation of litigation. Instead, Carrillo's allegations included other actions by Kearney that interfered with her rights as a homeowner.
The court ruled, "Kearney does not show these actions were protected under the anti-SLAPP statute, and thus, he fails to meet his initial burden of showing that the entire cause of action arose from protected conduct." This ruling was made without specifying the judge's name, but it was part of a decision by Justices Mori, Zukin, and Daum.
The court's decision has implications for future property disputes involving CC&Rs and anti-SLAPP motions. It clarifies that not all actions taken by a party in relation to enforcing CC&Rs are protected under the anti-SLAPP statute. This ruling may affect how homeowners and neighbors approach disputes regarding property improvements and the enforcement of CC&Rs.
Going forward, the ruling sets a precedent that could influence similar cases. Homeowners facing disputes over CC&Rs may find it more challenging to use anti-SLAPP motions to dismiss claims against them. The court's decision underscores the importance of demonstrating that all alleged acts of wrongdoing are protected under the anti-SLAPP statute.
As for what’s next, Kearney may have the option to appeal the decision further, although details were not available in the court filing. The case highlights ongoing tensions in property law and the complexities surrounding the enforcement of CC&Rs.
Read Next
Hawaii Court Affirms Denial to Seal Protective Order Records
Mississippi Supreme Court Reverses City Attorney Termination
Mississippi Supreme Court clarifies healthcare surrogate law
California Court denies mother's petition for reunification
California Court dismisses appeal in Mohaddess v. Patel case
Tax Court Rules on Income Tax Dispute for Georgia Couple










