A New York court has ruled that Terel Marshburn is entitled to unemployment benefits after his employment with the Ithaca Downtown Business Improvement District (BID) ended. The Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York issued its decision on November 19, 2026, in a case that has implications for how misconduct is defined in unemployment claims.

This ruling affects Marshburn, who worked as the director of operations for the Ithaca BID from June 2022 until August 2023. The decision is significant as it clarifies the standards for determining whether an employee's actions constitute disqualifying misconduct when applying for unemployment benefits.

Background

The case stems from a dispute between Terel Marshburn and his former employer, the Ithaca Downtown Business Improvement District Inc. Marshburn was responsible for managing and improving the downtown area of Ithaca, New York. His employment ended after the organization appointed a new executive director in the summer of 2023.

Following the leadership change, the Ithaca BID conducted an internal assessment and accused Marshburn of having an unauthorized second job with a private security company. They claimed he misused the employer's resources for this side job. After being offered the option to resign instead of facing termination, Marshburn accepted and later filed for unemployment benefits.

The New York Department of Labor initially disqualified Marshburn from receiving benefits, citing misconduct as the reason for his job loss. However, after a hearing, an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) overturned this decision, stating that the evidence did not support the claim of misconduct. The Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board subsequently affirmed the ALJ's ruling, prompting the Ithaca BID to appeal the decision.

The Ruling

The Appellate Division upheld the decision of the Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board, affirming that Marshburn was entitled to unemployment benefits. The court ruled that the determination of whether an employee has engaged in disqualifying misconduct is a factual issue for the Board to resolve. The court stated, "[W]hether an employee has engaged in disqualifying misconduct is a factual issue for the Board to resolve and its determination will be upheld if supported by substantial evidence."

The judges on the panel included Garry, P.J., Aarons, Fisher, McShan, and Corcoran. The court emphasized that it could not weigh conflicting evidence or substitute its own judgment for that of the Board. The court noted that the Board credited Marshburn's testimony, which indicated he believed he was acting within the scope of his employment when he assisted the private security company.

Marshburn testified that a previous executive director had assigned him a liaison role to help the security company secure contracts. The court found that this testimony was credible and supported the conclusion that Marshburn did not engage in misconduct that would disqualify him from receiving unemployment benefits.

Impact

This ruling has important implications for employees and employers alike. It clarifies that the burden of proof lies with the employer to demonstrate that an employee's actions constitute disqualifying misconduct. The court's decision reinforces the idea that employees may not be penalized for actions they reasonably believe are part of their job responsibilities, especially when those actions are sanctioned by a supervisor.

The ruling also highlights the importance of employee handbooks and training in defining acceptable workplace conduct. In this case, the Ithaca BID argued that Marshburn violated the organization's code of ethics by using company resources for outside employment. However, the court found that Marshburn's belief that he was acting in line with his job duties was reasonable, which ultimately led to the affirmation of his eligibility for benefits.

What's Next

The Ithaca Downtown Business Improvement District has the option to appeal the ruling further, although details on any potential appeal were not available in the court filing. There is no indication of any related cases pending that would impact this decision.