A New Jersey court has vacated a previous order requiring Brian J. Diehl to reimburse Kim M. Friedlander for therapy costs related to their child. The ruling affects the couple's ongoing custody arrangement and financial responsibilities. The decision highlights the importance of clear evidence in family court cases.
The case, Brian J. Diehl v. Kim M. Friedlander, was filed under docket number A-0956-25 in the New Jersey Superior Court Appellate Division. The court's decision came after Diehl appealed a portion of an August 8, 2025, non-dissolution order that mandated he pay $1,100 for therapy expenses incurred by their child. The ruling is significant as it emphasizes the need for adequate documentation when seeking reimbursement for child-related expenses.
Brian J. Diehl and Kim M. Friedlander are the parents of two children. Their relationship ended shortly after the birth of their second child. They share equal parenting time and have previously agreed on how to handle unreimbursed medical expenses, extracurricular activities, and childcare costs. A July 2018 order established their proportional net incomes, with Friedlander at seventy-six percent and Diehl at twenty-four percent.
In July 2023, Friedlander sought reimbursement for various out-of-pocket expenses, including therapy sessions for one of their children. Both parents agreed that therapy was necessary, and Friedlander claimed to have paid $4,650 for the sessions, seeking $1,110 from Diehl based on their income percentages. Initially, the court denied Friedlander's request for reimbursement in November 2023. However, after an appeal, the court found that the original ruling lacked adequate findings of fact and conclusions of law, leading to a remand for further consideration.
On remand, the court issued a new order that again denied Friedlander's request for reimbursement. Following this, Friedlander moved for reconsideration. On August 8, 2025, the court reversed its earlier stance, ordering Diehl to reimburse Friedlander for twenty-four percent of the therapy costs, amounting to $1,110. The court's reasoning included a review of the payments Diehl claimed to have made toward therapy costs.
The court stated, "As to therapy costs, [p]laintiff indicated that he has reimbursed [d]efendant for costs. However, the amount of $1,500 [p]laintiff paid was payment for therapy in October 2021, which is not the timeframe in which [d]efendant is requesting a reimbursement for." The court noted that Diehl's submissions did not adequately demonstrate that he had reimbursed Friedlander for the therapy sessions in question.
In its decision, the court acknowledged the importance of sufficient evidence when determining reimbursement for therapy costs. It highlighted that the receipts provided by Diehl showed therapy visits ending on March 4, 2021, and that there was no evidence to support claims for therapy sessions in the months of April, May, June, or October 2021. The court concluded that the lack of documentation made it impossible to uphold the reimbursement order.
The court ruled, "A claim for reimbursement of therapy costs must rest on competent evidence the trial court can rely upon to draw its legal conclusions." As a result, the court vacated the order requiring Diehl to reimburse Friedlander and remanded the case for a new hearing to determine the actual costs owed and any payments already made by Diehl.
This ruling underscores the necessity for parents involved in custody disputes to maintain clear and accurate records of expenses related to their children. It also emphasizes the court's commitment to ensuring that financial obligations are based on credible evidence.
Looking ahead, the case will return to the lower court for a new hearing to assess the evidence and determine the appropriate amount, if any, that Diehl owes Friedlander for the therapy costs. The court did not retain jurisdiction, meaning that further appeals may be possible depending on the outcome of the new proceedings.
Read Next
New Jersey court affirms DWI conviction of Chetan Soni
Court upholds ruling in Huzien v. Duran personal injury case
New Jersey Court Rules on Debt Collection Practices Case
Court orders review of records request by Haverstick, Kleinbard
Court upholds Pennsylvania State Police records denial
Court rules on immunity in Morales v. Montgomery County case










