The Hawaii Intermediate Court of Appeals has dismissed the appeal of Youngjae Jung after confirming his death during the ongoing litigation. This decision affects the legal proceedings involving multiple parties, including Dae Han Shipping Agency, Inc. The ruling emphasizes the importance of procedural compliance in appellate cases, particularly when a party passes away.

This case, identified by docket number CAAP-24-0000361, revolves around a dispute between Jung and Tong Jin Su, who is the representative of Dae Han Shipping Agency. The court's decision to dismiss Jung's appeal is significant as it underscores the legal requirements for substituting a deceased party in ongoing appeals.

Background

The parties involved in this case include Tong Jin Su, who is both an individual and a representative of Dae Han Shipping Agency, Inc., and Youngjae Jung, the defendant in the appeal. The case began in the Circuit Court of the First Circuit, where an Amended Final Judgment was entered in favor of Su on June 24, 2024. Following this judgment, Jung filed an appeal, and Dae Han Shipping subsequently cross-appealed.

The situation became complicated when it was reported that Jung had died on February 10, 2026, in South Korea. This information was disclosed by Jung's attorney, Christopher J. Muzzi, who filed a notice of suggestion of death. The court required Muzzi to provide further details regarding Jung's death and whether a personal representative had been appointed to handle Jung's estate.

The Ruling

The court ruled on November 17, 2026, that Jung's appeal would be dismissed due to the failure to substitute a personal representative for Jung within the specified time frame. The court noted, "if a motion to substitute under [Hawai#i Rules of Appellate Procedure (HRAP)] Rule 43(a) is not filed within forty-five (45) days of this order, then Jung's appeal may be dismissed."

Since no motion was filed to substitute for Jung within the 45-day deadline set by the court, the dismissal was deemed necessary. The court also granted Muzzi’s motion for relief from the requirement to file a certified copy of Jung's death certificate, acknowledging the difficulties in obtaining such documentation from South Korea.

Impact

This ruling has implications for the ongoing litigation involving Dae Han Shipping Agency, as Jung's appeal is no longer active. The dismissal highlights the procedural requirements under Hawaii law regarding the death of a party during an appeal. Specifically, HRAP Rule 43(a) outlines the process for substituting a deceased party, which is crucial for maintaining the integrity of appellate proceedings.

As a result of this ruling, the focus will now shift to Dae Han Shipping's cross-appeal. The outcome of that appeal could still influence the final resolution of the case originally brought by Su against Jung and others. The dismissal of Jung's appeal may also serve as a reminder to parties involved in litigation to ensure compliance with procedural rules, especially when dealing with sensitive matters such as death.

What's Next

The dismissal of Jung's appeal does not preclude the possibility of further legal action regarding the matters at hand. Dae Han Shipping's cross-appeal remains active and will continue through the court system. Details regarding any potential appeals or additional related cases were not available in the court filing.