The Hawaii Intermediate Court of Appeals has affirmed a ruling in a loan dispute involving Madeleine M. McKay and Hubert Guez. The court's decision, filed on November 18, 2026, addresses issues related to loans and trust management, impacting how financial agreements are enforced among individuals.

This case stems from a long-standing friendship between McKay and Guez. After McKay's husband passed away in 2001, Guez advised her on financial matters. Between 2003 and 2005, Guez executed eight promissory notes documenting loans totaling $3,150,000 from McKay's trusts. Each note specified the principal amount and interest rates, which varied between 5% and 12%. The notes allowed McKay to demand payment with three or six months' notice.

In 2018, McKay demanded full payment from Guez, including interest, but he failed to comply. This led McKay to file a lawsuit against Guez, resulting in a summary judgment in her favor. Guez appealed this decision, and the Intermediate Court of Appeals found that while Guez's indebtedness was clear, the circuit court had erred in determining the exact amounts owed, prompting a remand for further proceedings.

On remand, the circuit court held an evidentiary hearing where it was established that Guez had received the total loan amount of $3,150,000 but had only paid back $75,000 toward the principal. McKay's expert accountant, Garret J. Hoe, prepared two reports estimating Guez's total debt, factoring in payments made and interest accrued. The court ultimately determined that Guez owed McKay $5,187,638 in principal and interest and awarded her daily interest and reasonable fees.

Guez appealed again, raising two main points of error. He argued that the circuit court improperly excluded testimony regarding payments he made and accepted expert testimony as substantive evidence regarding the amounts owed. However, the court ruled that Guez did not adequately challenge the circuit court's findings and that his claims lacked sufficient evidence for review.

The court ruled that "uncontested findings are binding on this court" and noted that Guez's credibility regarding oral modifications to the loan terms was not credible.

The ruling by the Intermediate Court of Appeals, which included judges Keith K. Hiraoka, Clyde J. Wadsworth, and Sonja M.P. McCullen, reinforces the importance of clear documentation and adherence to financial agreements, particularly in trust management scenarios. The court emphasized that it would not disturb the circuit court's credibility determinations and that conflicting evidence must be resolved at the trial level.

This decision impacts individuals involved in similar financial arrangements, highlighting the need for proper record-keeping and the importance of credible testimony in legal disputes. The ruling also serves as a reminder that failure to adequately challenge findings in a lower court can lead to unfavorable outcomes on appeal.

Looking forward, it remains unclear if Guez will pursue further legal action or if there are related cases pending. The court filing did not provide details on potential appeals or future proceedings.