An Illinois appellate court has upheld a ruling against Vincent and Lekeisha Williams, homeowners in the Ashford Farms subdivision, for violating their homeowners association's (HOA) fence regulations. The court's decision, filed on November 17, 2026, confirms that the couple must relocate their fence, which was erected without the necessary approval from the association's architectural committee.
The case, Ashford Farms Homeowners Association v. Williams (Docket No. 5-25-0405), highlights the importance of compliance with HOA rules and the enforcement of restrictive covenants intended to maintain community standards. The ruling underscores the authority of homeowners associations to regulate property modifications within their communities.
The dispute began when the Ashford Farms Homeowners Association filed a complaint against the Williamses after they installed a fence on their property without obtaining prior approval. The association argued that the fence violated the subdivision's restrictive covenants, which require homeowners to seek permission before making exterior changes. The trial court ruled in favor of the association, ordering the Williamses to move their fence to a location approved by the board.
Background
The Ashford Farms Homeowners Association is a not-for-profit corporation established to manage and enforce community standards in the Ashford Farms subdivision in St. Clair County, Illinois. The restrictive covenants, filed in 2011, outline the rules for property modifications, including the installation of fences. The covenants state that homeowners must obtain approval from the board or an architectural committee before making any changes to their property.
The Williamses, who own a home in the subdivision, erected a fence in June 2023 without the necessary approval. The association notified them of the violation and provided a 30-day period to comply with the covenants. Despite this, the couple did not take action to rectify the situation, prompting the association to seek legal enforcement.
During the trial, the association presented evidence that the Williamses' fence was not in compliance with the established guidelines. Testimony revealed that the architectural committee had denied their request for a fence placement that extended to the front of their home. The defendants argued that their fence complied with the covenants and claimed that the association had selectively enforced the rules against them.
The Ruling
The appellate court, presided over by Justice Clarke, affirmed the trial court's decision, stating that the evidence supported the finding that the Williamses had violated the restrictive covenants. The court noted, "The trial court’s finding that the defendants violated the plaintiff homeowners’ association’s restrictive covenants was not against the manifest weight of the evidence."
The court emphasized that the defendants had failed to obtain the required approval from the architectural committee before erecting their fence. It also dismissed the defendants' claims of selective enforcement, stating that they did not provide sufficient evidence to support their assertions. The ruling confirmed that the architectural committee had the authority to approve or deny fence placements and that the defendants did not comply with the terms of the covenants.
Impact
This ruling reinforces the legal standing of homeowners associations to enforce their rules and regulations. It serves as a reminder to homeowners about the importance of adhering to community standards and obtaining the necessary approvals before making modifications to their properties. The decision may also deter other homeowners from ignoring HOA rules, as it establishes a precedent for the enforcement of restrictive covenants.
Moreover, the court's ruling clarifies that claims of selective enforcement must be substantiated with evidence. Homeowners who believe they are being treated unfairly by their associations must present concrete proof to support their claims. This case illustrates the challenges that homeowners may face when contesting HOA decisions without adequate documentation or legal representation.
What's Next
The Williamses have the option to appeal the decision to a higher court, although details regarding any potential appeal were not available in the court filing. Meanwhile, the Ashford Farms Homeowners Association can proceed with enforcing the court's order, requiring the defendants to relocate their fence to a location that complies with the established covenants.
Read Next
Illinois court affirms revocation of James Walker's pretrial release
Illinois court reverses murder conviction of Amari Robinson
Illinois court affirms dismissal of Nash's postconviction petition
Vermont court denies motion to amend wrongful death complaint
Vermont court dismisses eviction case against Catherine Morrill
Vermont court rules on timber harvest dispute case









