The Montana Supreme Court ruled on November 17, 2026, in the case of Robert Witmer v. Mojo Geological Consulting, LLC, regarding a wrongful discharge complaint. The court's decision impacts how personal jurisdiction is determined in employment cases, especially those involving companies that operate across state lines.

Robert Witmer, a resident of Missoula, Montana, appealed the dismissal of his wrongful discharge complaint against Mojo Geological Consulting, LLC. The Fourth Judicial District Court in Missoula County had dismissed his complaint with prejudice, citing a lack of personal jurisdiction over Mojo, which is organized as a limited liability company in Wyoming. This ruling affects not only Witmer but also sets a precedent for similar cases involving companies that have moved their organizational status to another state.

The dispute arose when Witmer alleged that he was wrongfully terminated from his job with Mojo after failing a drug test in June 2024. Witmer claimed he had been employed satisfactorily since 2018 and sought relief under the Montana Wrongful Discharge from Employment Act. Mojo, however, argued that the court lacked jurisdiction because it was no longer registered as a Montana company, having domesticated in Wyoming in 2018.

The case reached the Montana Supreme Court after Witmer filed an appeal against the district court's ruling. The court had concluded that Witmer failed to establish either general or specific personal jurisdiction over Mojo. Witmer argued that Mojo's operations in Montana and its employment of a Montana resident should suffice to establish jurisdiction.

In its ruling, the Montana Supreme Court affirmed the district court's decision regarding the jurisdictional issues but reversed the dismissal with prejudice. Justice Katherine M. Bidegaray delivered the opinion of the court, stating, "The organizational history does not establish that Mojo remained organized under Montana law when Witmer brought this action." The court emphasized that Mojo's domestication in Wyoming and subsequent termination in Montana meant it was not subject to Montana's jurisdiction at the time of Witmer's discharge.

The court clarified that while Witmer had presented evidence of Mojo's business activities in Montana, these did not establish that Mojo was "essentially at home" in Montana. The ruling pointed out that the legal standard for general jurisdiction requires a company to have substantial and continuous operations in the state, which Mojo did not meet after its domestication in Wyoming.

Furthermore, the court discussed specific jurisdiction, which focuses on the relationship between the defendant, the forum, and the litigation. Witmer had argued that the actions of Mojo's president, who discharged him, should subject the company to jurisdiction in Montana. However, the court found that this argument failed because Mojo was not organized under Montana law at the time of the discharge.

As a result, the Montana Supreme Court reversed the district court's decision to dismiss Witmer's complaint with prejudice. Instead, the court instructed the lower court to enter a dismissal without prejudice, allowing Witmer the opportunity to potentially refile his complaint in the appropriate jurisdiction.

This ruling has significant implications for future cases involving wrongful discharge claims, particularly for employees of companies that operate across state lines. It underscores the importance of understanding a company's jurisdictional status and how it affects an employee's ability to bring claims in their home state.

Looking forward, Witmer may choose to refile his complaint in Wyoming, where Mojo is currently organized. The decision does not preclude him from seeking relief, but it does highlight the complexities involved in wrongful discharge cases that cross state lines.

Overall, the Montana Supreme Court's ruling clarifies the standards for personal jurisdiction in employment law and sets important precedents for how similar cases will be handled in the future.