A New York appellate court has dismissed an appeal concerning a custody dispute between a mother and father over their two children. The court ruled that the appeal was not properly before them due to procedural issues. This decision affects the custody arrangement that was previously established in Franklin County.
The case, known as Matter of Sasha NN. v. Mathew NN., was decided on November 19, 2026, by the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York. The ruling is significant as it clarifies the procedural requirements for appealing custody decisions in family court.
The parties involved in the case are Sasha NN., the mother, and Mathew NN., the father. They share two children, born in 2011 and 2013. The dispute began when the mother moved to Clinton County and sought to modify a previous custody order that had granted the father sole legal and physical custody of the children.
The initial custody arrangement was established by the Franklin County Family Court on April 22, 2024. Under this order, the mother was granted supervised parenting time. After moving, the mother filed a petition in Clinton County Family Court in July 2024, seeking to change the custody arrangement.
However, the attorney for the children involved in the case moved to transfer the petition back to Franklin County. The Clinton County Family Court, led by Referee Brendon Dupree, agreed to this transfer. The mother then appealed this decision, leading to the current ruling.
The appellate court's decision focused on the nature of the order that transferred the case. The court noted that an order of transfer is considered a nondispositional order, which means it does not resolve the underlying issues of the case. As such, the court stated, "there is no appeal as of right from a nondispositional order in a Family Ct Act proceeding." Because the mother did not seek permission to appeal, the court ruled that the appeal was not properly before them.
Additionally, the court highlighted that the father had moved to dismiss the mother's petition for failure to prosecute. In an order dated August 29, 2025, the Franklin County Family Court dismissed the mother's petition due to her failure to appear in court. This dismissal further complicated the mother's appeal, as the court noted that the parties would not be directly affected by the appeal.
Judges Clark, Reynolds Fitzgerald, McShan, Mackey, and Ryba concurred in the decision to dismiss the appeal without costs. The ruling emphasizes the importance of following proper procedures when appealing family court decisions, particularly in custody cases.
The impact of this ruling is significant for parents involved in custody disputes. It underscores the necessity for individuals to adhere to procedural rules when seeking to challenge decisions made by family courts. Failure to do so can result in the dismissal of appeals, leaving existing custody arrangements unchanged.
Going forward, this case may serve as a precedent for similar cases in New York. Parents seeking to modify custody arrangements must ensure they follow the correct legal procedures, including seeking permission to appeal when necessary. This ruling may also influence how family courts handle future custody disputes, particularly regarding jurisdiction and procedural compliance.
As for what’s next, it is unclear whether the mother plans to seek further legal action regarding her custody rights. The court did not provide details on any related cases or potential appeals. However, the ruling leaves the existing custody arrangement in place, pending any new developments.
Read Next
Court modifies ruling on attorneys' fees in Galleria case
Court orders New York to disclose certain public records
Court upholds JPMorgan Chase's trust accounting in Rockefeller case
Hawaii Supreme Court denies petition for extraordinary writ
Court affirms dismissal of Marc Stephens' claims against CareOne
California Court rules against employer's arbitration clause










