A Pennsylvania court has denied a father's request to modify an existing custody order, which would have granted him primary physical custody of his twelve-year-old son. The ruling, issued on November 16, 2026, by Judge Bowes, affirms the earlier decision made by the Mercer County Court of Common Pleas. This decision is significant as it underscores the court's emphasis on the child's best interests in custody matters.
The case involves J.T. Marcus, formerly known as Justin Wayne Turnbaugh, who has been in a protracted custody dispute with Sherrie Elizabeth Hassan, the mother of their son, S.T. The custody battle began in 2020 when Marcus first sought custody arrangements for S.T. and his older daughter, S.N.H. Since then, the court has awarded Hassan primary physical custody of S.T., while Marcus has had partial custody.
In 2023, Marcus proposed relocating to Haslet, Texas, to live with his partner, Adina Enlow. At that time, he sought to modify his custody arrangement to include more time with S.T. This request led to a court hearing where the judge granted him limited relief, allowing him to have custody for one weekend a month in Pennsylvania and seven consecutive days during the summer in Texas. However, Marcus later filed a petition for emergency relief, alleging parental alienation and abuse by Hassan, which prompted a series of hearings.
During the hearings, the court heard testimony from both parents, witnesses, and even conducted interviews with S.T. Ultimately, the trial court increased Marcus's custody time during the summer but did not grant his request for primary custody. The court found that removing S.T. from his established environment and support system in Pennsylvania would not be in the child's best interests.
In its ruling, the court stated, "Considering all factors in total, there is not sufficient evidence to completely remove [S.T.] from his entire family, other than Father, his school, supports, hobbies, and church, and move him to Texas." The court emphasized the importance of S.T.'s relationships with his family, school, and community, noting that he has a strong bond with both parents and his extended family in Pennsylvania.
The court's decision was based on several factors outlined in Pennsylvania's Child Custody Act, which prioritizes the child's safety and well-being. The court evaluated both parents' histories, including allegations of abuse and the children's preferences. While S.T. expressed a desire to live with his father, the court deemed that his preference was not well-reasoned and considered the impracticality of the proposed custody arrangement.
The court also addressed the safety-related factors, noting that both parents had histories of conflict and that there was insufficient evidence to support a complete change in custody. The court found that, despite some past incidents, both parents could provide adequate safeguards for S.T.
The ruling has implications for future custody cases in Pennsylvania, as it reinforces the importance of maintaining stability and continuity in a child's life. The court's decision highlights the need for thorough evaluations of all factors affecting a child's well-being, especially in cases involving relocation and custody modifications.
Moving forward, Marcus has the option to appeal the decision, although the court's ruling is based on a comprehensive review of the evidence presented. The case underscores the complexities of custody disputes and the critical role that courts play in determining the best interests of children involved.
Details were not available in the court filing regarding any related cases pending or further actions that may be taken by either party.
Read Next
Pennsylvania court upholds lengthy sentence for animal cruelty
Pennsylvania Court Upholds SVP Designation for Newman
Pennsylvania Court Affirms Life Sentence for Ali Marsh
Pennsylvania court vacates order modifying custody arrangement
Illinois court revives homeowner's lawsuit against garage builder
Tennessee Supreme Court Rules on Liquidated Damages Case










