The Superior Court of Pennsylvania has ruled to vacate an order from the Washington County Court that modified a custody arrangement between parents Carmine Bloise Jr. and Hannah Bassler. The decision, issued on November 16, 2026, is significant as it highlights the importance of jurisdiction in family law cases, particularly those involving protection from abuse (PFA) orders.
This ruling affects Carmine Bloise Jr., who sought the PFA order, and Hannah Bassler, the mother of their ten-year-old child, J.B. The case underscores the legal complexities surrounding custody disputes and the procedural requirements that must be met for modifications to court orders.
Background
Carmine Bloise Jr. and Hannah Bassler have been engaged in a custody battle concerning their child, J.B. The conflict escalated when Bloise obtained a temporary PFA order on January 27, 2026, alleging that Bassler had abused their child. Following a hearing on February 4, 2026, the Washington County court issued a final PFA order that limited Bassler's custody rights to supervised visitation.
However, on March 26, 2026, a separate ruling from Allegheny County Judge Cathleen Bubash granted Bassler sole physical and legal custody of J.B. This decision prompted further legal actions, leading to the April 1, 2026, order from the Washington County court, which attempted to modify the earlier PFA order without a formal request from either party.
The Ruling
The Superior Court, led by Judge Dubow, determined that the Washington County court lacked jurisdiction to modify its prior order. The ruling stated, "the April 1, 2026 order is a legal nullity because the trial court lacked jurisdiction to modify its prior order." The court emphasized that modifications to a final PFA order require a petition for modification, service of that petition, and a hearing, none of which occurred in this case.
Judge Dubow's opinion clarified that the Washington County court lost jurisdiction to modify the PFA order after thirty days, stating, "in the absence of a motion for reconsideration, a petition for modification, or a patent error, the PFA court lost jurisdiction on March 6, 2026." As a result, the court vacated the April 1, 2026, order and relinquished jurisdiction.
Impact
This ruling reinforces the procedural safeguards in place for modifying custody and PFA orders. It highlights the necessity for courts to adhere strictly to jurisdictional requirements, ensuring that parties receive due process. The decision serves as a reminder that even in emotionally charged custody disputes, legal procedures must be followed to protect the rights of all parties involved.
The court's ruling has implications for similar cases in Pennsylvania, emphasizing that any modifications to custody arrangements must follow the established legal framework. This case will likely influence how lower courts handle future custody modifications, ensuring that proper procedures are observed to avoid jurisdictional issues.
What’s Next
While the April 1, 2026, order has been vacated, the custody arrangement established by the Allegheny County court remains in effect. There is no indication that this decision will be appealed, but any future custody disputes may arise as circumstances change. Details were not available in the court filing regarding any related cases or potential appeals.
Read Next
Pennsylvania court upholds lengthy sentence for animal cruelty
Pennsylvania Court Upholds SVP Designation for Newman
Pennsylvania Court Affirms Life Sentence for Ali Marsh
Illinois court revives homeowner's lawsuit against garage builder
Tennessee Supreme Court Rules on Liquidated Damages Case
Pennsylvania court denies father's custody modification request










