The Texas Court of Appeals recently ruled in favor of Southgate Homes DFW, LLC, Southgate Homes-Brockdale LLC, and Green Brick Partners, Inc., reversing a lower court's decision that awarded damages to Sherman and Eunice Guillema. The court's decision, issued on November 17, 2026, in case number 05-24-00620-CV, highlights significant implications for homebuyers and builders regarding contract disputes and claims under the Texas Deceptive Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Act (DTPA).

The Guillemas, who were planning to move from California to Texas, sought to purchase a home in the Brockdale Estates community. They signed a contract with Southgate Homes for the construction of a semi-custom home. However, the contract was never executed by Southgate, leading to a dispute over alleged misrepresentations and nondisclosures by the builders. The Guillemas claimed that they relied on the builders' assurances that the contract would be signed, which led them to halt their home search during a competitive housing market.

The case reached the Texas Court of Appeals after a jury found in favor of the Guillemas, awarding them damages for violations of the DTPA and fraud by non-disclosure. The jury's award included compensation for the “lost increase in market value” of the home they intended to purchase and the “reasonable value” of their time spent pursuing the contract. However, the builders appealed the verdict, arguing that the Guillemas could not recover damages due to the lack of a binding contract.

In its ruling, the court determined that the Guillemas' claims could not bypass the Statute of Frauds, which requires certain contracts to be in writing to be enforceable. The court stated, "Because there is no bargain that is binding, there can be no recovery for these benefit-of-the-bargain damages." This effectively meant that since the contract was never executed, the Guillemas could not claim damages based on the anticipated benefits of that contract.

The court also found that the jury's award for the “reasonable value” of the Guillemas' time was unsupported by sufficient evidence. The Guillemas had claimed that they spent significant time preparing for the home purchase, but the court ruled that there was no clear quantification of this time or its value presented during the trial. The court concluded that the Guillemas were entitled to no damages, effectively reversing the lower court's judgment.

This ruling has significant implications for future homebuyers and builders in Texas. It underscores the importance of having a fully executed contract in place before relying on representations made by builders or sellers. The decision also clarifies the boundaries of recoverable damages in cases involving alleged fraud and misrepresentation in real estate transactions.

Moving forward, homebuyers may need to exercise greater caution and ensure that all agreements are formally executed before halting their property searches or making significant decisions based on verbal assurances. Builders, on the other hand, may need to be more transparent in their communications to avoid similar disputes.

As for the Guillemas, they may have the option to appeal the ruling to the Texas Supreme Court, although it remains to be seen whether they will pursue this route. The outcome of this case could set a precedent affecting how contract disputes are handled in the Texas real estate market.