The Arizona Court of Appeals has affirmed a protective order against Diana Bernstein, stemming from allegations of harassment by her former partner, Dameon McEntyre-Shurtleff. This ruling, filed on November 17, 2026, in case number 1 CA-CV 26-0585 FC, highlights the court's stance on domestic violence and harassment claims, emphasizing the importance of protecting individuals from potential harm.

The case centers around the tumultuous relationship between Bernstein and McEntyre-Shurtleff, who separated in July 2025 after having a child together. Following their separation, McEntyre-Shurtleff reported multiple incidents that raised his concerns about Bernstein's behavior. He discovered tracking devices on his vehicle three times and received messages from Bernstein that indicated she was aware of his whereabouts. Additionally, he alleged that Bernstein communicated false information to his workplace, claiming he had committed theft and fraud.

As tensions escalated, Bernstein reportedly sent numerous messages to McEntyre-Shurtleff, including claims about an intimate video of the couple that he did not consent to being recorded or shared. Bernstein also entered his residence without permission, which was captured by a security camera. These incidents led McEntyre-Shurtleff to seek a protective order, which was initially granted ex parte by the court. Bernstein contested this order, leading to a hearing where both parties presented their evidence.

During the hearing, the court found that Bernstein had committed acts of domestic violence against McEntyre-Shurtleff. The judge ruled that there was sufficient evidence to continue the protective order, which included a Brady indicator, a designation that indicates the potential for future violence. Judge Brian Y. Furuya delivered the court's decision, which was supported by Presiding Judge Jennifer M. Perkins and Judge D. Andrew Gaona. The court stated, "The evidence showed Bernstein’s conduct was not trivial and, in fact, caused McEntyre-Shurtleff serious alarm or mental distress."

The ruling emphasized that the court's role is to assess the credibility of the evidence presented and to make determinations based on the facts. The court found that McEntyre-Shurtleff had proven his case by a preponderance of evidence, which is the standard required in such protective order proceedings. The court also noted that harassment, as defined under Arizona law, includes actions that cause a reasonable person to feel alarmed or distressed.

In affirming the protective order, the court rejected Bernstein's claims that there was no objective evidence of harassment. It stated that the messages Bernstein sent to McEntyre-Shurtleff, particularly regarding the alleged intimate video, constituted harassment and contributed to McEntyre-Shurtleff's mental distress. The court's decision illustrates the seriousness with which it treats allegations of domestic violence and harassment.

The impact of this ruling extends beyond the parties involved. It reinforces the legal protections available to individuals who may be victims of domestic violence and harassment. The court's decision serves as a reminder that the law provides avenues for individuals to seek protection when they feel threatened or unsafe. This case highlights the importance of taking such allegations seriously and the role of the court in ensuring the safety of individuals in domestic situations.

Looking ahead, the ruling can be appealed to a higher court, but it remains to be seen if Bernstein will pursue that option. The court's decision sets a precedent in how similar cases may be handled in the future, particularly regarding the evidence required to uphold protective orders. It also underscores the significance of addressing domestic violence and harassment in a legal context, providing a framework for future cases.

In conclusion, the Arizona Court of Appeals' affirmation of the protective order against Diana Bernstein underscores the court's commitment to protecting individuals from harassment and domestic violence. The ruling not only affects the parties involved but also serves as a critical reminder of the legal protections available to victims of such behavior.