The Arizona Court of Appeals recently reversed a ruling that terminated a mother’s parental rights to her 17-year-old child, A.F. The court found that the mother did not abandon her child, as the child consistently refused to engage with her. This decision has significant implications for parental rights and the interpretation of abandonment in custody cases.
The case, titled In Re Termination of Parental Rights as to A.F., was filed under docket number 1 CA-JV 26-0063 on November 17, 2026. The ruling came from Judge D. Andrew Gaona, with the support of Presiding Judge Jennifer M. Perkins and Judge Brian Y. Furuya. The court's decision highlights the importance of considering a child's expressed wishes in parental rights cases.
Background
The parties involved in this case are the mother of A.F., who is not named in the ruling, and the child's guardian, who is also the child's stepfather. The guardian sought to terminate the mother's parental rights, claiming that she had abandoned A.F. The relationship between the mother and child deteriorated after a dependency case was filed by the Department of Child Safety in 2022 due to allegations of sexual abuse involving A.F. and his half-siblings.
Following the dependency case, a family court awarded the guardian third-party custody of A.F. and established a Supervision Order that allowed the mother supervised visitation with her child. However, the order also stated that A.F. had the right to refuse visitation. Despite the mother's attempts to communicate with A.F. and express her desire to maintain a relationship, the child consistently declined any contact.
The Ruling
The Arizona Court of Appeals ruled that the superior court had abused its discretion in terminating the mother's parental rights. The court stated, "the law does not compel useless things," emphasizing that the mother could not be found to have abandoned A.F. when the child had the right to refuse visitation and had done so repeatedly.
The court noted that the superior court had concluded that the guardian had proven abandonment based on the mother’s failure to make a good-faith effort to maintain contact. However, the appellate court found that the evidence showed the mother had made multiple attempts to reach out to A.F. and that further requests would have been futile. The ruling stated, "Mother is correct—she didn’t ‘abandon’ Child when Child consistently invoked his right to refuse visitation." The court ultimately reversed the termination order, concluding that the guardian failed to prove abandonment by clear and convincing evidence.
Impact
This ruling is significant for several reasons. It reinforces the importance of a child's expressed wishes in custody and parental rights cases. The court’s decision suggests that a parent cannot be deemed to have abandoned a child if the child actively refuses contact and the parent has made reasonable efforts to maintain a relationship. This case may set a precedent for future cases involving parental rights and abandonment, particularly in situations where a child's refusal to engage is a central factor.
Moreover, the ruling could influence how courts interpret the concept of abandonment in similar cases moving forward. It highlights the need for courts to consider the context of a parent-child relationship and the child's autonomy in deciding whether to maintain contact.
What’s Next
The guardian may still pursue adoption of A.F. once the child turns 18, as Arizona law allows for adoption without parental consent in such cases. The ruling can be appealed, but details regarding any potential appeal were not specified in the court filing.
Read Next
Arizona Court affirms attorney fee award in divorce case
Arizona court rules on Nicholas Didur's civil rights appeal
Arizona court upholds $1 jury award in negligence case
Vermont court denies motion to dismiss in workplace case
Vermont court upholds small claims judgment against Feinberg
Pennsylvania court affirms child support ruling in Burda case










