The California Court of Appeal has affirmed a judgment against Herbert Werker in his employment lawsuit against Dr. Jovan Plamenac and his dental practice, West Coast Smiles. This ruling, filed on November 18, 2026, affects Werker, who claimed he was wrongfully terminated and not paid for his work. The court's decision highlights the challenges self-represented litigants face when navigating the legal system.
Werker filed his initial complaint on October 13, 2020, asserting a breach of contract claim against Dr. Plamenac. As the case progressed, he amended his complaint to include additional defendants, including West Coast Smiles, and expanded his claims to include wrongful termination, retaliation, and other labor violations. The dispute arose after Werker alleged he was hired to care for Dr. Plamenac's sister, Olivera, who suffered from memory loss. He claimed that over time, his responsibilities increased without additional pay, leading to his wrongful eviction from the home.
The conflict escalated when Dr. Plamenac issued a letter demanding Werker move out, which he refused. Following this, Werker found his belongings removed from the home and was served with a Temporary Restraining Order (TRO) accusing him of elder abuse. This TRO forced him to leave the residence, resulting in his homelessness.
As the case unfolded, Dr. Plamenac filed a motion to strike many of Werker's claims, which the trial court granted. This ruling eliminated several of Werker's allegations, including wrongful termination and emotional distress claims. In February 2024, Werker dismissed two defendants from the case. The remaining claims proceeded to trial, where the court ultimately ruled against him.
On September 30, 2025, the court entered judgment in favor of Dr. Plamenac and West Coast Smiles, awarding them attorney fees and costs. Following this, Werker filed a notice of appeal, challenging the judgment and the court's previous rulings.
The court ruled that Werker failed to provide a clear argument or adequate record for review. The opinion stated, "Because Werker has failed to provide this court with any cogent argument to support reversal or an adequate record to conduct a meaningful review of the judgment, we must affirm." The judges involved in the ruling included Presiding Justice McConnell, Justice Do, and Justice Amin.
This ruling underscores the difficulties faced by self-represented litigants in the legal system. The court noted that even though Werker represented himself, he was not exempt from following the rules of appellate procedure. His claims were deemed unclear and unsubstantiated, leading to the court's conclusion that he forfeited his right to appeal.
The impact of this ruling is significant for Werker, as it affirms the lower court's decision and highlights the importance of presenting a well-structured argument in legal proceedings. It serves as a reminder that self-represented individuals must adhere to the same legal standards as those represented by attorneys.
Looking ahead, Werker may consider seeking further legal counsel to explore any potential options for appeal or other legal avenues. However, the court's affirmation of the judgment indicates that the path forward may be challenging without a more robust legal strategy.
Read Next
Court upholds summary judgment in Taylor v. Anderson case
Court affirms murder conviction of Deshawn Wallace
California court remands case for resentencing under new law
Court denies father's child support request in Pennsylvania
Illinois court affirms property classification in divorce case
Ninth Circuit dismisses foreclosure appeal for lack of jurisdiction









