The Connecticut Supreme Court recently ruled that process servers are entitled to charge for copies of legal documents, even if they did not personally make those copies. This decision affects how fees are handled in civil actions and clarifies the interpretation of a specific statute regarding process server compensation.

The case, Francis v. Fonfara (SC18480), involved State Marshal Lisa H. Stevenson, who sought to recover $900 for copies of a complaint she served in a civil action against all 185 members of the Connecticut General Assembly. The court's ruling has implications for process servers across the state, ensuring they are compensated for their work in handling and verifying legal documents.

Background

The underlying action was initiated by Ernest Francis, who filed a declaratory judgment action against the members of the Connecticut General Assembly, including John W. Fonfara. Francis received a waiver for the entry fee and service fees, placing the responsibility for payment on the state. Stevenson, the process server, was tasked with serving the complaint to all defendants.

Stevenson received a box of copies made by Francis' son and confirmed that they met the legal requirements. She then submitted an invoice for her services, which included a charge for the copies. However, the trial court disallowed the fee for copies, leading Stevenson to file a writ of error, seeking to overturn that decision.

The Ruling

The Connecticut Supreme Court, led by Justice Eveleigh, ruled in favor of Stevenson. The court found that the trial court had improperly denied her request for fees, stating, "the fee for copies is not contingent upon the process server personally making the copies." The court emphasized that the statute governing process server fees was ambiguous and required interpretation.

The court analyzed General Statutes § 52-261 (a) (2), which allows process servers to charge for copies of legal documents. The justices noted that the statute does not explicitly require the process server to make the copies themselves to receive payment. The court concluded that the fee compensates the process server for handling and ensuring the accuracy of the copies, regardless of who physically made them.

Impact

This ruling has significant implications for process servers in Connecticut. It clarifies that they can charge for copies of documents, even if they did not make those copies themselves. This decision may lead to increased fees claimed by process servers, as they will now be compensated for their role in ensuring that legal documents are accurate and properly served.

The ruling also sets a precedent for how similar cases may be handled in the future, potentially influencing legislative discussions about process server compensation. The court's analysis of the statute and its legislative history highlights the importance of understanding the intent behind laws that govern fees and services in the legal system.

What's Next

The trial court must now comply with the Supreme Court's ruling and award Stevenson the requested fee for copies. There is no indication in the court filing that this decision will be appealed, and it appears to resolve the specific issue regarding process server fees in this case.