The New Jersey Tax Court has ruled in a case involving the Borough of Matawan and the Monmouth County Board of Taxation regarding a proposed annual reassessment for the tax year 2027. The court's decision, issued on November 22, 2026, affects local taxpayers and sets the stage for future tax assessments in the borough.
The court granted Matawan a temporary stay on the reassessment process, which will remain in effect while the court hears the merits of Matawan's challenge. This ruling is significant as it addresses the legal requirements surrounding property tax assessments and the authority of local tax boards.
Background
The dispute began when Matawan filed a complaint on September 2, 2026, against the Monmouth County Board of Taxation and the Division of Taxation. Matawan sought to void an approval for an annual reassessment for the tax year 2027, arguing that the county board and the state taxation division had not complied with the necessary regulations. The borough's complaint included 182 allegations, claiming that the actions taken by the county board and taxation were arbitrary and unreasonable.
Matawan's complaint also pointed out that the Chapter 123 ratio for the borough was 97.95% for the tax year 2026, which is close to the ideal 100%. The borough argued that there was no need for a reassessment given the stability of the current assessments. Additionally, Matawan sought to dissolve the Real Property Assessment Demonstration Program (ADP), which had expired in 2018, and to withdraw from it.
On October 12, 2026, Matawan applied for an Order to Show Cause, requesting that the court prevent the county board from enforcing the reassessment. The court initially issued a temporary stay on October 16, 2026, halting the issuance of assessment notices until the matter could be resolved.
The Ruling
The court ruled to maintain the temporary stay on the reassessment process. Judge Mala Sundar stated that the stay would preserve the status quo while the court considered the merits of Matawan's complaint. The court found that lifting the stay would cause irreparable harm to Matawan's taxpayers, leading to confusion and additional expenses.
The court noted, "The court finds that Matawan has met the Crowe tests," referring to the criteria for granting a preliminary injunction.
The ruling also bifurcated the issues raised in Matawan's complaint, meaning the court will first address the allegations related to the 2027 reassessment. A hearing on this matter is scheduled for December 10, 2026. The court aims to issue a decision shortly thereafter, allowing for timely issuance of assessment notices.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for Matawan and its taxpayers. By maintaining the stay, the court has prevented the county board from moving forward with the reassessment until the legal questions surrounding its necessity are resolved. This decision may set a precedent for how similar cases are handled in the future, particularly regarding the authority of tax boards and compliance with assessment regulations.
The ruling also highlights the importance of clear communication and adherence to legal requirements in the property tax assessment process. If the court ultimately rules in favor of Matawan, it could lead to changes in how annual reassessments are conducted in New Jersey.
What's Next
The upcoming hearing on December 10, 2026, will be crucial in determining the future of the reassessment process for Matawan. Depending on the court's decision, there may be further appeals or related cases that arise from this ruling. Additionally, the court plans to consolidate this case with other pending complaints regarding similar issues, which could streamline the legal process for all parties involved.
Read Next
New Jersey court affirms murder conviction of Hollingsworth
Court upholds dismissal of welfare benefits lawsuit in NJ
Court rules on New Jersey school segregation lawsuit
Court rules on foreclosure irregularity in Zalewski case
Hawaii Court Rules Against Public Safety Department in Appeal
Hawaii Court Reverses Labor Board Ruling on Officer's Case










