The Texas Court of Appeals has reversed a lower court's ruling in a case involving disbarred attorney R. Kent Livesay and several law firms, including Kaster, Lynch, Farrar & Ball, LLP, and Farrar & Ball, LLP. The court's decision, issued on November 5, 2026, allows Livesay to continue his legal battle for attorney's fees he claims are owed to him under a fee-sharing agreement.

This case matters because it addresses the legal rights of disbarred attorneys to collect fees for work completed before their licenses were revoked. The ruling could have implications for other attorneys in similar situations, as well as for law firms that may have engaged in fee-sharing agreements with disbarred lawyers.

Background

R. Kent Livesay was a practicing attorney in Texas until the Texas Supreme Court revoked his law license on July 6, 2018. Before his disbarment, Livesay referred client matters to the law firms involved in this case, with whom he had fee-sharing agreements. These agreements stipulated that he would assume joint responsibility for the representation of the clients.

Livesay's legal troubles began in January 2017 when his law license was suspended. He notified the law firms of his suspension, and they subsequently signed new representation agreements with the affected clients, effectively removing Livesay from their cases. In 2022, Livesay filed a lawsuit against the law firms, claiming he was owed attorney's fees and expenses for work he completed before his disbarment.

The Ruling

The Texas Court of Appeals ruled that the trial court erred in granting summary judgment in favor of the law firms. The court found that Livesay had raised valid objections to one of the affidavits submitted by the law firms and that there was insufficient evidence to support the claim that he had not completed his work on the client matters before his license was revoked. The opinion was authored by Justice Tonya McLaughlin.

The court ruled, "the law firms had the burden to establish that paying Livesay on any of the fee-sharing agreements at issue was illegal or against public policy."

Additionally, the court stated that Livesay could potentially recover attorney's fees for work completed prior to his disbarment, as long as he fulfilled his responsibilities under the fee agreements. The court emphasized that the law firms did not provide competent evidence to conclusively prove that Livesay had abandoned his responsibilities before the client matters were resolved.

Impact

This ruling has significant implications for disbarred attorneys seeking to recover fees for work performed before their disbarment. The court's decision reinforces the principle that disbarred attorneys may still be entitled to recover fees for completed work, provided they can demonstrate that they fulfilled their obligations to the clients involved.

The ruling also sets a precedent for how courts may interpret fee-sharing agreements involving disbarred attorneys in the future. It highlights the importance of competent evidence in summary judgment motions and the need for law firms to clearly establish the timeline of client matters when contesting claims for unpaid fees.

What's Next

The case has been remanded to the lower court for further proceedings, where Livesay will have the opportunity to present his claims regarding the unpaid fees. The law firms may also have the chance to provide additional evidence to support their defense. It remains unclear whether the law firms will appeal this decision to a higher court.