A New York appellate court has ruled against Zachery Alabadi, affirming a determination that he maltreated his three children. The decision, issued on November 20, 2026, by the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court, highlights the challenges faced by individuals seeking to amend or seal reports of child maltreatment.
This ruling affects Alabadi and his family, as it maintains the validity of the indicated report of child maltreatment in the New York State Central Register of Child Abuse and Maltreatment. The case underscores the rigorous standards involved in child welfare proceedings and the importance of substantial evidence in such determinations.
Background
Zachery Alabadi initiated this legal proceeding against Sheila J. Poole, who represents the New York State Office of Children and Family Services (OCFS), along with the New York State Central Register. The dispute arose when Alabadi sought to amend an indicated report of child maltreatment that was filed against him concerning his three children.
The case reached the Appellate Division after Alabadi's request to have the report amended to “unfounded” and sealed was denied by the OCFS following a fair hearing. The initial determination was made by an Administrative Law Judge, who found that the evidence supported the claim of maltreatment.
The Ruling
The Appellate Division unanimously confirmed the OCFS's determination, dismissing Alabadi's petition. The court ruled that the evidence presented at the fair hearing was sufficient to support the conclusion that Alabadi had maltreated his children. The opinion stated, "Our review... is limited to whether the determination was supported by substantial evidence in the record on the petitioner['s] application for expungement."
The judges on the panel included Whalen, Lindley, Ogden, Nowak, and Delconte. They emphasized that credibility issues arising from conflicting versions of events are typically resolved by the Administrative Law Judge, and their assessments will not be disturbed if supported by substantial evidence.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for Alabadi and others in similar situations. By upholding the OCFS's determination, the court reinforced the standards required for expunging reports of child maltreatment. The decision suggests that individuals seeking to amend such reports must present compelling evidence to counter the findings of maltreatment.
Moreover, the ruling serves as a reminder of the legal complexities surrounding child welfare cases. It illustrates the challenges parents face when dealing with allegations of maltreatment and the stringent requirements for overturning such findings. The court's reliance on substantial evidence sets a precedent for future cases involving child protection and maltreatment claims.
What's Next
Details were not available in the court filing regarding whether Alabadi plans to appeal this decision. There may also be related cases pending that involve similar issues of child maltreatment reporting and expungement.
Read Next
Court rules on insurance coverage in Ratava, LLC case
Court affirms murder conviction of Elwell McPhail in NY case
Court upholds ruling in Smith v. Jett personal injury case
Nevada court affirms custody ruling in Capparelli case
Ohio Court reverses dismissal of complaint against officials
Court affirms dismissal of claims against Specialized Loan










