A New York appellate court has upheld a ruling that holds property owner David N. Charron liable for injuries sustained by Benjamin E. Irwin while cleaning the roof of a rental property. The decision, made on November 20, 2026, emphasizes the importance of safety measures under Labor Law § 240 (1) and clarifies the responsibilities of property owners regarding worker safety.
The case, titled Irwin v. Charron (Docket No. 699 CA 25-01643), centers around an accident that occurred when Irwin fell from the roof while performing maintenance work. This ruling is significant as it reinforces the legal protections afforded to workers engaged in activities that involve elevation-related risks, even when they may not be using safety devices.
In this case, Benjamin and Barbara Irwin, the plaintiffs, sought damages after Benjamin fell while cleaning the vinyl siding on Charron's rental property. At the time of the accident, Irwin was not using any safety devices. The dispute arose when Charron argued that Irwin's own negligence was the sole cause of the accident and that Labor Law § 240 (1) should not apply because Irwin was performing routine maintenance work.
The case reached the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York after Charron appealed a lower court's decision. The Supreme Court had granted Irwin's cross-motion for partial summary judgment on liability under Labor Law § 240 (1) and denied Charron's motion to dismiss the complaint. The court's ruling was based on the interpretation of what constitutes a covered activity under the law.
The appellate court unanimously affirmed the lower court's decision, stating that Charron was strictly liable for the violation of Labor Law § 240 (1). The court noted that cleaning activities can fall under the statute's protections if they present hazards comparable to those found on construction sites. The court emphasized, "[C]leaning is a covered activity under Labor Law § 240 (1) and, although 'routine, household window washing' does not fall within the ambit of section 240 (1), it does apply to 'other types of cleaning projects that present hazards comparable in kind and degree to those presented on a construction site.'"
Furthermore, the court rejected Charron's argument that Irwin's negligence was the sole proximate cause of the accident. It stated, "The elements of a sole proximate cause defense are that the plaintiff (1) had adequate safety devices available, (2) knew both that the safety devices were available and that [the plaintiff was] expected to use them, (3) chose for no good reason not to do so, and (4) would not have been injured had [the plaintiff] not made that choice." The court found that Charron had not provided any safety devices, which contributed to the accident.
The ruling also addressed Charron's attempt to amend his answer to include a cross-claim for common-law indemnification against Irwin. The court denied this request, stating that allowing such a claim would undermine the purpose of Labor Law § 240 (1), which is designed to protect workers from elevation-related risks. The court pointed out that liability under this statute is imposed without regard to concepts of negligence, reinforcing the idea that a property owner cannot shift blame to an injured worker.
This decision has significant implications for property owners and contractors in New York. It underscores the necessity for providing adequate safety measures to workers engaged in tasks that involve risks associated with elevation. The ruling clarifies that even if a worker does not use available safety devices, the property owner can still be held liable if they failed to provide those devices in the first place.
Going forward, this ruling may influence how property owners approach safety regulations and their responsibilities towards workers. It reinforces the legal expectation that property owners must ensure safety measures are in place to protect individuals working on their properties, especially in situations that involve potential hazards.
Details about whether Charron plans to appeal the decision were not available in the court filing. However, the ruling sets a clear precedent regarding the application of Labor Law § 240 (1) and the responsibilities of property owners in ensuring worker safety.
Read Next
Court rules on child neglect case involving Darcie C.
Court upholds Monroe County's condemnation of Target Corp. rights
New York court upholds murder conviction of Robert Coffin
Court affirms decision on worker's loss of earning capacity
Court affirms jury's decision in medical malpractice case
Court rules on medical negligence case dismissal appeal










