The Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals recently ruled against Kenneth and Kayla Rogers, who sought to intervene in a class action settlement involving Wells Fargo Bank related to a COVID-19 mortgage forbearance program. The court's decision, issued on November 20, 2026, affirmed the lower court's ruling that denied the couple's request to join the case, which affects thousands of customers who were part of the settlement.

The ruling matters because it clarifies the criteria for intervention in class action lawsuits, particularly regarding the definition of class members and the importance of timely action. The Rogerses believed they were wrongly excluded from the settlement class, which could have implications for others in similar situations.

Background

The parties involved in this case are the Rogerses, who are homeowners with a mortgage serviced by Wells Fargo, and Wells Fargo Bank, which faced class action lawsuits from customers alleging unauthorized forbearances during the pandemic. The lawsuits were consolidated, and after nearly four and a half years of litigation, a settlement agreement was approved by the district court.

The Rogerses discovered the settlement in January 2025, shortly after it was approved. They believed they should have been included in the class because their mortgage was placed in forbearance during the relevant time period. However, when they contacted the class counsel, they were informed that their exclusion was not an error. In March 2025, they filed motions to intervene in the litigation, claiming they met the criteria to be part of the class.

The Ruling

The Sixth Circuit, led by Judge Chad A. Readler, upheld the district court's decision to deny the Rogerses' motions to intervene. The court stated, "We see no error on either count and affirm," indicating that the Rogerses did not meet the necessary criteria to intervene as outlined in Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 24(a)(2).

The court explained that to successfully intervene, the Rogerses needed to demonstrate four key elements: their request was timely, they had a substantial legal interest in the case, their ability to protect that interest would be impaired without intervention, and the existing parties would not adequately protect their interests. The court found that the Rogerses failed to satisfy these requirements.

Regarding the timeliness of their request, the court noted that the case had progressed significantly by the time the Rogerses sought to intervene. The settlement had already been approved, and payments to class members were being processed. The court emphasized that allowing intervention at such a late stage would likely prejudice the settling parties.

Impact

The ruling has significant implications for individuals who believe they were wrongfully excluded from class action settlements. It underscores the importance of understanding class definitions and the necessity of timely intervention. The court's decision reinforces that late intervention requests, especially after a settlement has been reached, are often denied.

Moreover, the ruling clarifies that individuals who are not class members, like the Rogerses, do not have the same rights to intervene as those who are part of the class. This distinction is crucial for future cases and could influence how other potential intervenors approach similar situations.

What's Next

The Rogerses may still pursue their claims against Wells Fargo in separate litigation, as the court indicated that the settlement does not bar them from doing so. Details were not available in the court filing regarding any related cases or potential appeals.