The Arizona Court of Appeals has upheld a decision regarding Barbara Reitz, a former housekeeper, who sought compensation for loss of earning capacity (LEC) due to a work-related injury. The court ruled that Reitz did not demonstrate a loss of earning capacity stemming from her permanent impairment. This decision impacts Reitz’s ability to receive disability benefits and sets a precedent for similar cases involving workers' compensation claims.
Reitz, who was 70 years old at the time of her injury, sustained a lower back injury while employed by Community Bridges, Inc. Her claim for workers' compensation was accepted, and she received benefits. After reaching maximum medical improvement about 18 months post-injury, the Industrial Commission of Arizona (ICA) closed her claim, awarding her supportive care and a 6% permanent impairment rating. However, the ICA later determined that Reitz suffered no reduction in her earning capacity due to her injury.
Following this ruling, Reitz requested a hearing to contest the ICA's decision. The hearing focused on whether she had any loss of earning capacity, and if so, how much. Reitz presented evidence to support her claim for a full loss of earning capacity, while the respondents, including her employer and their insurance carrier, argued that she had not suffered a loss. The core of the dispute revolved around whether her prescribed work restrictions and medications for her back pain hindered her ability to work in any suitable job.
During the hearing, two doctors testified regarding Reitz's ability to work. Both agreed that she could perform light-duty work under certain conditions, such as avoiding lifting more than 20 pounds and not stooping or bending. Reitz's doctor confirmed that she was prescribed gabapentin and muscle relaxants, which caused drowsiness. Reitz testified that her medications affected her ability to work and that she faced challenges in finding employment due to her limited computer skills and vision issues.
Two labor market consultants provided differing opinions on Reitz's earning capacity. Consultant Nolan McKelvey concluded that she had likely experienced a complete loss of earning capacity due to her age, limited skills, and work restrictions. Conversely, consultant Lisa Clapp argued that Reitz could perform various jobs, including positions at a call center or as a receptionist, which would not result in a loss of earning capacity. Clapp believed that Reitz's vision issues were not significant enough to prevent her from working.
The administrative law judge (ALJ) found that while Reitz made a good-faith effort to find work, the evidence did not support her claim of a loss of earning capacity. The ALJ concluded that the drowsiness caused by her medications did not significantly hinder her ability to perform the jobs suggested by Clapp. As a result, the ALJ ruled that Reitz had no loss of earning capacity and was not entitled to disability benefits.
In its ruling, the Arizona Court of Appeals affirmed the ALJ's decision, stating, "reasonable evidence supports the ICA’s decision." The court emphasized that it would not re-weigh evidence presented at the hearing, as the ALJ had the authority to resolve conflicting evidence and determine which testimony was more credible. The court also noted that Reitz's arguments regarding the weight of her doctor's opinion did not warrant overturning the ALJ's findings.
This ruling has significant implications for Reitz and others in similar situations. It reinforces the importance of demonstrating a clear loss of earning capacity in workers' compensation claims. The decision highlights the need for claimants to provide substantial evidence, including expert testimony, to support their claims for disability benefits.
Going forward, this ruling may influence how courts handle similar cases regarding loss of earning capacity in workers' compensation claims. It sets a standard for the type of evidence required to establish a loss and underscores the role of medical and labor market experts in evaluating a claimant's ability to work.
As for Reitz, she may have the option to appeal the decision, but details about any potential appeal were not available in the court filing. The case serves as a reminder of the complexities involved in workers' compensation claims and the challenges faced by injured workers seeking benefits.
Read Next
Arizona court rules on property dispute between Bonitas and Olsen
Arizona court affirms resentencing of Seantain Cook
Arizona court affirms aggravated assault convictions
Court affirms dismissal of slip and fall case against hospital
Court reverses workers' compensation ruling in Deleon case
Texas Supreme Court sends car accident case back for review










