The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled against a Peruvian family seeking asylum in the United States, affirming the Board of Immigration Appeals' (BIA) decision. The court found that the family's claims did not meet the necessary legal standards for asylum, withholding of removal, or protection under the Convention Against Torture (CAT). This ruling affects Richard Castillo Hurtado, his wife Daniela Cruz, and their three children, who were seeking refuge from violence in Peru.
The case, Castillo Hurtado v. Blanche, was filed on November 20, 2026, under docket number 24-3734. The family argued that they faced persecution due to their political opinions and their social group status as victims of violence in Peru. However, the court concluded that their persecution was motivated solely by financial gain rather than any protected grounds.
Background
The petitioners in this case, Richard Castillo Hurtado, Daniela Cruz, and their three minor children, fled from Peru, claiming they were targeted by criminal groups. These groups allegedly sought to extort money from them. They applied for asylum and other protections, arguing that they faced threats due to their political opinions and as members of a particular social group consisting of Peruvian citizens persecuted by private actors.
Their case was initially heard by an Immigration Judge (IJ), who denied their applications for asylum and withholding of removal. The IJ's decision was based on the finding that the family had not sufficiently established a connection between the harm they experienced and any protected ground, such as political opinion or membership in a particular social group. The family then appealed to the BIA, which upheld the IJ's ruling.
The Ruling
The Ninth Circuit reviewed the BIA's decision and found substantial evidence supporting the denial of the family's asylum application. The court stated, "Substantial evidence supports the BIA’s denial of Petitioners’ applications for asylum and withholding of removal based on the finding that Petitioners were targeted exclusively for financial gain and not based on a protected ground." The judges on the panel included Circuit Judges Forrest and Tung, along with District Judge Bastian, who was sitting by designation.
The court emphasized that to qualify for asylum, applicants must show that a protected ground is "at least one central reason" for their persecution. The BIA had determined that the family's claims did not meet this requirement, as their lead petitioner testified that the criminal groups targeted them primarily for financial reasons. The court concluded that the BIA's findings were sufficient and did not warrant overturning the decision.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for the Castillo Hurtado family, as they now face the possibility of deportation back to Peru. It highlights the challenges faced by individuals seeking asylum in the United States, particularly when their claims are based on violence that may not be linked to protected grounds under U.S. immigration law. The court's decision reinforces the legal standard that applicants must meet to qualify for asylum, emphasizing the necessity of demonstrating a clear nexus between persecution and a protected ground.
The ruling also illustrates the importance of presenting a well-founded case when appealing to the BIA. The Ninth Circuit's affirmation of the BIA's decision indicates that future applicants must be prepared to substantiate their claims with compelling evidence that aligns with legal standards.
What's Next
The family may have limited options for further appeal. While they could potentially seek a rehearing or file a petition for review with the U.S. Supreme Court, the likelihood of success would depend on the specific legal grounds presented. Details were not available in the court filing regarding any related cases pending or additional appeals the family might pursue.
Read Next
Ninth Circuit denies Gambian man's immigration appeal
Ninth Circuit dismisses Badenock's immigration appeal
Ninth Circuit denies asylum petition of Rogelio Ramirez Lopez
Ninth Circuit denies petition from Salvadoran man facing removal
Ninth Circuit rules on immigration case of Joel Soto Muñoz
Ninth Circuit denies asylum petition for Colombian man










