The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled against a family from Honduras seeking asylum in the United States. The court's decision, issued on November 20, 2026, affects Jose David Hernandez Rodriguez and his family, who argued that returning to Honduras would put them at risk of persecution. This ruling is significant as it highlights the challenges many immigrants face when seeking asylum based on claims of persecution.
The family, which includes Hernandez, Eva Sarai Galo Robles, K.N.H.G., and L.C.H.G., filed a petition for review of a decision made by the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA). The BIA had dismissed their appeal of an immigration judge's (IJ) order that denied their applications for asylum, withholding of removal, and protection under the Convention Against Torture (CAT). The case is documented under docket number 24-3704.
The dispute began when the family applied for asylum, arguing that they faced threats and harm in Honduras. They claimed that the police were involved in criminal activities against them, including burglary and vandalism of their property. However, the BIA found that their claims did not meet the legal standards required for asylum and withholding of removal.
The case reached the Ninth Circuit after the family’s appeal to the BIA was dismissed. The BIA's decision was based on the IJ's findings, which the court noted it would review. The Ninth Circuit judges, including S.R. Thomas, Friedland, and Bress, evaluated the evidence presented by the family and the agency's conclusions.
The court ruled that the BIA's decision to deny the family's asylum claims was supported by substantial evidence. The judges stated, "Substantial evidence supports the agency’s determination that Hernandez’s past harm did not rise to the level of persecution." This means that the court found the evidence did not convincingly show that Hernandez suffered significant harm or threats that would qualify him for asylum.
The court highlighted that while Hernandez experienced unfortunate events in Honduras, such as an altercation with a police officer and threats, these did not constitute persecution. The judges noted that "persecution... is an extreme concept that means something considerably more than discrimination or harassment." They pointed out that Hernandez did not suffer significant physical injuries from his experiences, which played a crucial role in the court's decision.
Furthermore, the court emphasized that the family failed to demonstrate that they had a well-founded fear of future persecution if they returned to Honduras. The judges stated, "the agency could conclude that police patrols near the residence of Hernandez’s father do not demonstrate that police are looking for petitioners." This suggests that the court found the evidence of potential future threats to be insufficient.
In addition to the asylum claims, the family also sought protection under CAT. However, the court noted that the petitioners did not challenge the agency's conclusion regarding their ineligibility for CAT protection. As a result, the court ruled that they forfeited any challenge to this aspect of their case.
The ruling has significant implications for the Hernandez family and others in similar situations. It underscores the difficulties faced by asylum seekers in proving their claims of persecution. The Ninth Circuit's decision also illustrates the high burden of proof required for individuals seeking asylum in the United States, particularly those from countries with known violence and instability.
Moving forward, this ruling may set a precedent for similar cases in the Ninth Circuit, where the court has consistently upheld the need for substantial evidence to support claims of persecution. The decision may also impact how lower courts and immigration judges assess asylum claims from individuals facing threats in their home countries.
As for the Hernandez family, they have the option to appeal the Ninth Circuit's decision. However, details regarding the possibility of further legal action were not available in the court filing. The family’s situation remains uncertain as they continue to navigate the complexities of the U.S. immigration system.
Read Next
Ninth Circuit denies Gambian man's immigration appeal
Ninth Circuit dismisses Badenock's immigration appeal
Ninth Circuit denies asylum petition of Rogelio Ramirez Lopez
Ninth Circuit denies petition from Salvadoran man facing removal
Ninth Circuit rules on immigration case of Joel Soto Muñoz
Ninth Circuit denies asylum petition for Colombian man










