The Arizona Court of Appeals has affirmed a lower court's decision regarding parenting time and child support obligations in the case of Javier Maranon, Jr. v. Ayerim Garcia, No. 1 CA-CV 26-0024 FC. This ruling, issued on November 20, 2026, impacts both parents and their child, born in March 2019, as it modifies the previous arrangements established in 2023.
The case centers on a dispute between Maranon and Garcia over their parenting rights and financial responsibilities. The initial order granted joint legal decision-making but designated Garcia as the parent with final authority. Following a series of hearings and motions, the court ultimately modified the parenting plan and child support obligations, which has significant implications for both parents and their child.
In 2020, Maranon filed a petition to establish paternity, legal decision-making, parenting time, and child support. After a lengthy trial that spanned from April 2022 to August 2023, the superior court issued its final orders in October 2023. The court found both parents capable of parenting and ordered Maranon to pay $149 per month in child support. However, this decision was challenged by Garcia, who raised concerns about their child's well-being and the appropriateness of the parenting time schedule.
In November 2023, Garcia filed a motion to amend the October 2023 order, arguing that the court had relied on unsupported findings and that new evidence indicated potential issues with their child's behavior, which warranted a reconsideration of the parenting time orders. Maranon opposed this motion, asserting that the court could not consider events that occurred after the trial concluded.
In March 2025, the superior court held a hearing on Garcia's motion and Maranon's petition to modify child support. The court allowed new evidence to be presented regarding the child's well-being and the parents' interactions. Following this hearing, the court issued its October 2025 order, which modified the parenting time arrangement and increased Maranon's child support obligations.
The court ruled that the child was not well-adjusted to the existing parenting time schedule and expressed concerns about Maranon's mental health and his lack of support for therapy. The court found that Maranon's behavior and failure to comply with disclosure requirements hindered its ability to assess his mental health accurately. As a result, the court reduced Maranon's parenting time and increased his child support obligation to $622 per month.
The court stated, "The child is not well adjusted to parenting time with Father, particularly the schedule established in 2023."
Additionally, the court awarded Garcia $57,298.80 in attorneys’ fees, citing Maranon's conduct that unnecessarily prolonged the litigation process. Maranon subsequently appealed the October 2025 order, claiming that the court lacked authority to modify parenting time and that it violated his due process rights.
In its ruling, the Arizona Court of Appeals found that the superior court did not err in modifying parenting time and that the record supported an implied finding of changed circumstances affecting the child's welfare. The appellate court emphasized that the superior court had broad discretion in managing evidence and did not violate Maranon's due process rights during the hearings.
The court noted that Maranon's failure to disclose relevant medical information and his late filing of supplemental evidence were valid reasons for the court's decisions. The appellate court also affirmed the superior court's findings regarding Maranon's earning capacity, stating that his VA disability rating did not establish an inability to work, and upheld the award of attorneys’ fees to Garcia.
This ruling reinforces the importance of timely disclosures and the need for parents to demonstrate their ability to provide a stable environment for their children. It also highlights the court's commitment to prioritizing the best interests of the child in custody and support matters.
Moving forward, this ruling may serve as a reference for similar cases involving parenting time and child support modifications in Arizona. The decision underscores the necessity for parents to comply with court orders and the potential consequences of failing to do so.
As for next steps, Maranon has the option to appeal the ruling further, but details regarding any potential appeals or related cases were not available in the court filing.
Read Next
Arizona court affirms aggravated assault convictions
Arizona court affirms termination of father's parental rights
Arizona court affirms juvenile delinquency ruling for G.M.
Court Rules on Legal Fee Advancement for Heppner Case
Wyoming Supreme Court rules on family dispute over property
Kansas court upholds denial of release for Jimmie Sebek










