A Texas court has dismissed a petition for writ of mandamus filed by Rachael Pagitt against the Honorable Clinton Davis, a judge in Henderson County. The court ruled that the case became moot after the lower court complied with its order regarding discovery requests.

This ruling affects Pagitt, who sought to challenge a discovery order that allowed certain requests from Morris Gross. The Texas Court of Appeals, 12th District, issued its opinion on November 18, 2026, under docket number 12-26-00297-CV.

The case began when Pagitt filed her petition on September 25, 2026, to contest an order from Judge Clinton Davis. The order had granted discovery requests that Pagitt argued were not authorized under the Texas Citizens Participation Act (TCPA). The TCPA is designed to protect individuals from lawsuits that aim to silence their free speech rights.

Background

Rachael Pagitt is the relator in this case, meaning she is the party seeking relief from the court. Morris Gross is identified as the Real Party in Interest, which typically refers to the party opposing the relator in a legal dispute. The original proceeding was filed in response to a discovery order issued by Judge Clinton Davis of the 173rd District Court in Henderson County.

The dispute arose from a legal action involving Pagitt and Gross, where Gross sought certain discovery materials from Pagitt. Pagitt contended that these requests were overly broad and not permitted under the protections afforded by the TCPA. This led her to file a petition for a writ of mandamus, which is a court order directing a lower court or government official to properly fulfill their official duties.

The Ruling

The Texas Court of Appeals reviewed Pagitt's petition and conditionally granted it in part on October 30, 2026. The court directed Judge Davis to vacate specific portions of his September 14, 2026, order that allowed discovery not authorized under the TCPA. The court stated, "the writ should not issue" and ultimately dismissed the petition as moot after the lower court complied with its directive.

In its final judgment, the court noted, "the said petition for writ of mandamus be, and the same is, hereby dismissed as moot." This ruling indicates that since the lower court had already taken the necessary actions to comply with the appellate court's order, there was no longer a need for further judicial intervention.

Impact

This ruling has significant implications for similar cases involving the Texas Citizens Participation Act. It reinforces the importance of adhering to the protections offered by the TCPA, particularly regarding discovery requests that may infringe upon individuals' rights to free speech and participation in public discourse.

By dismissing the case as moot, the court effectively closed the door on Pagitt's challenge, but it also highlighted the necessity for lower courts to carefully consider the scope of discovery requests in light of the TCPA. This case may serve as a reference point for future disputes involving the act and the limits of discovery in civil litigation.

What's Next

Details were not available in the court filing regarding whether Pagitt plans to appeal the ruling or if there are related cases pending. However, since the court dismissed the petition as moot, the immediate legal battle regarding this specific discovery issue appears to have concluded.