The South Dakota Supreme Court recently upheld the candidacy of Celestine Stadnick for the State Senate in District 27, dismissing challenges raised by her opponent, Anthony Kathol. The court ruled that sufficient valid signatures supported Stadnick's nomination despite claims of discrepancies in her candidacy paperwork. This decision is significant as it clarifies the requirements for candidate nominations in South Dakota and may influence future electoral challenges.
In the case, Kathol filed an affidavit with the South Dakota Secretary of State, alleging that Stadnick's candidacy was invalid due to defective signatures on her nominating petitions and a discrepancy between the address on her declaration of candidacy and her voter registration. The Secretary of State, however, found that while some signatures were indeed invalid, there were enough valid ones to certify Stadnick's candidacy. Kathol subsequently appealed this decision to the circuit court, which upheld the Secretary's ruling. Kathol then took the matter to the South Dakota Supreme Court, which ultimately affirmed the lower court's decision.
Background
Anthony Kathol and Celestine Stadnick were both candidates vying for the State Senate seat in District 27, which encompasses parts of Bennett, Jackson, Pennington, and Oglala Lakota counties. Stadnick submitted her nomination petition, which included 155 signatures, well above the 50 required by South Dakota law for certification. However, Kathol contested her candidacy, citing an address discrepancy and challenging the validity of several signatures on her petition.
Kathol's affidavit highlighted that Stadnick's declared address did not match her registered voter address. He claimed that South Dakota law mandates that a candidate can only claim one principal address. Additionally, he challenged the validity of 100 signatures, arguing that they were not compliant with the law. The Secretary of State reviewed these challenges, invalidated some signatures, but ultimately concluded that Stadnick had enough valid signatures to proceed with her candidacy.
After the Secretary's decision, Kathol appealed to the circuit court. During the court proceedings, he reiterated his concerns regarding the address discrepancy and challenged additional signatures, some of which he had not previously mentioned in his affidavit. The circuit court allowed these new challenges but ultimately found that the Secretary's decision was justified and upheld Stadnick's candidacy.
The Ruling
The South Dakota Supreme Court ruled on the appeal, affirming the circuit court's decision. The court stated, "The circuit court did not err when determining that Stadnick complied with the nominating petition requirements." The justices clarified that the Secretary of State's determination of substantial compliance with the signature requirements was appropriate.
Justice Scott P. Myren, writing for the court, emphasized that there is no South Dakota law requiring a candidate’s declaration of candidacy address to match their voter registration address. The court found that Kathol's claims regarding the address discrepancy were unfounded, noting that the Secretary had correctly ruled that the listing of “Oglala” instead of “Oglala Lakota” was sufficient for compliance with the law.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for future elections in South Dakota. It reinforces the idea that minor discrepancies in candidate declarations may not necessarily invalidate a candidacy, as long as there is substantial compliance with the law. This decision could deter frivolous challenges to candidacies based on technicalities, thereby promoting a more streamlined electoral process.
The ruling also sets a precedent that could influence how similar cases are handled in the future. Candidates and their opponents may need to be more cautious about the grounds on which they challenge nominations, as the court has shown a willingness to uphold candidates who meet the essential requirements, even if there are minor discrepancies.
What's Next
Details were not available in the court filing regarding whether Kathol plans to appeal the decision further. As of now, Stadnick remains certified as a candidate for the State Senate in District 27, and no related cases are pending.














