The South Dakota Supreme Court recently ruled on a case involving a domestic abuse protection order. The court affirmed the lower court's decision to deny the order sought by Kayden Kursave against Tertius Van Der Mescht. This ruling, issued on November 18, 2026, is significant as it clarifies the criteria for establishing a significant romantic relationship in cases involving domestic abuse claims.

The case began when Kursave filed for a domestic abuse protection order on January 30, 2026, after Van Der Mescht showed up uninvited at her home. The court's decision affects not only the parties involved but also sets a precedent for how similar cases may be handled in the future.

Background

Kursave and Van Der Mescht began dating in March 2024 and got engaged later that year. However, their relationship was tumultuous, with multiple breakups, including a final separation in February 2025. After their breakup, Van Der Mescht attempted to contact Kursave several times, including an uninvited visit to her workplace and sending her a picture of a tattoo of her name on his body.

The situation escalated when Van Der Mescht appeared at Kursave's home on January 30, 2026. He knocked on her door and opened it without her permission, leading to a confrontation where he questioned her about her new boyfriend. This incident prompted Kursave to seek a protection order, claiming that Van Der Mescht's actions constituted stalking and harassment.

The circuit court initially granted a temporary protection order but later denied the request for a permanent one after a hearing. The court found that Van Der Mescht's actions did not meet the legal definition of domestic abuse as outlined in South Dakota law.

The Ruling

The South Dakota Supreme Court, led by Chief Justice Steven R. Jensen, affirmed the lower court's ruling. The court found that the circuit court did not clearly err in its decision. The opinion stated, "The court found no evidence of threatening or harassing behavior as defined by law because of the time between incidents and the lack of a 'pattern of conduct with a series of acts over a period of time.'"

The court emphasized that while Kursave may have felt alarmed by Van Der Mescht's actions, the evidence did not support a finding of stalking or domestic abuse. The court noted that there was a significant gap in time between incidents, and Van Der Mescht's visit was characterized as a brief argument rather than a pattern of harassment.

Impact

This ruling has important implications for future domestic abuse cases in South Dakota. It clarifies the definition of a significant romantic relationship and the criteria needed to establish a pattern of conduct that constitutes domestic abuse. The court's decision reinforces the need for clear evidence of repeated harassment or stalking behavior, which may make it more challenging for individuals to obtain protection orders in similar situations.

Furthermore, the ruling highlights the importance of the context in which actions occur, as the court considered the time elapsed since the last contact between the parties. This may influence how courts evaluate claims of domestic abuse and the evidence required to support such claims.

What's Next

Details were not available in the court filing regarding whether Kursave plans to appeal the decision. There are no related cases pending that were mentioned in the opinion. However, this ruling may prompt discussions about the legal standards for domestic abuse protection orders in South Dakota.