The California Court of Appeal has upheld a commitment order for Reuben David Patino, who is charged with multiple counts related to stalking and violating a court order. The court's decision, filed on November 17, 2026, comes after Patino's defense raised questions about his mental competency. This ruling is significant as it clarifies the standards for competency proceedings and the requirements for a defendant to request a change of counsel.
Patino, facing serious charges in two separate cases, was declared incompetent to stand trial after a series of psychological evaluations. His appeal focused on whether the trial court erred by not holding a hearing to address his dissatisfaction with his appointed counsel. The court's ruling is crucial for defendants in similar situations, as it outlines the necessary steps they must take to ensure their legal representation meets their needs.
Background
The case involves Reuben David Patino, who has been charged in two cases: CR2024-3462 and CR2024-3647. The charges include stalking and multiple counts of violating a court order. On November 5, 2024, during the proceedings, Patino's defense counsel raised concerns about his mental competency. Following this, the trial court initiated competency proceedings under California law.
Two doctors evaluated Patino's mental state, with one concluding that he was incompetent to stand trial. After several missed court appearances, including one on January 30, 2025, due to illness, the court ultimately ordered Patino's commitment on February 10, 2025. Patino appealed this commitment order, arguing that the trial court failed to conduct a hearing regarding his request for new counsel, as outlined in the landmark case People v. Marsden.
The Ruling
The California Court of Appeal affirmed the trial court's commitment order, concluding that there was no error in failing to hold a Marsden hearing. The court stated, "[w]e will not find error on the part of the trial court for failure to conduct a Marsden hearing in the absence of evidence that [the] defendant made his desire for appointment of new counsel known to the court." This ruling was made by Acting Presiding Judge Hull, with Judges Mauro and Damrell concurring.
The court examined Patino's letters to the trial court, which he argued indicated his desire for a Marsden hearing. However, the court found that these letters did not clearly articulate a request for substitute counsel. The court noted that Patino's statements expressed dissatisfaction with his attorney but did not formally request a new one. The court concluded that even if Patino had requested a Marsden hearing, he abandoned that request by failing to appear in court for subsequent hearings.
Impact
This ruling has important implications for defendants facing similar situations. It clarifies that a defendant must clearly express a desire for new counsel for a trial court to be obligated to hold a Marsden hearing. The court emphasized that a defendant's actions, such as failing to attend hearings, can be interpreted as abandoning any request for a change in representation. This case reinforces the need for defendants to actively pursue their requests for counsel changes and to be present during hearings related to their cases.
Additionally, the decision highlights the balance courts must maintain between respecting a defendant's attorney-client relationship and ensuring that defendants have adequate representation. The ruling serves as a reminder that defendants must be proactive in communicating their needs to the court to avoid potential pitfalls in their legal proceedings.
What's Next
Patino's commitment order has been affirmed, but he may still have options for further legal action. It is unclear if he plans to appeal this decision to a higher court. Additionally, there may be related cases pending that could further explore issues of competency and representation in the context of criminal proceedings.
Read Next
Court affirms murder conviction of Deshawn Wallace
California court remands case for resentencing under new law
California Court upholds termination of parental rights in ICWA case
Pennsylvania court upholds conviction of Kamal Tunnell
Pennsylvania Court Denies Appeal in Domestic Assault Case
Pennsylvania Court Upholds Conviction of Tyrone C. Mason










