In a recent ruling, the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York addressed a case involving a construction worker's injury. The court's decision, issued on November 17, 2026, affects workers in the construction industry and clarifies the application of Labor Law protections in similar cases.
The case, titled Lazo v. Bay Ridge Automotive Management Corp., centers around Manuel Jesus Zhinin Lazo, a concrete worker who sustained injuries when a heavy brace fell on his leg at a construction site. The court's ruling is significant as it highlights the limitations of Labor Law protections for workers injured on the job.
Lazo, who was employed by Glenco Contracting Group, Inc., claimed that the brace, which weighed 100 pounds and measured 18 feet long, fell while workers were moving it. This incident raised questions about workplace safety and the responsibilities of various parties involved in construction projects.
Background
The dispute arose from an incident where Lazo was injured at a construction site managed by Bay Ridge Automotive Management Corp. Lazo filed a lawsuit against several defendants, including Redcom CM Inc. and Glenco Contracting Group, alleging violations of Labor Law § 241(6). This law is intended to protect construction workers by ensuring safe working conditions.
The case reached the Appellate Division after a lower court, presided over by Justice David B. Cohen, ruled on motions for summary judgment. Lazo sought to have his claims validated, while the defendants argued that they were not liable for his injuries. The case was filed under Index No. 155564/20 and Appeal No. 7509, with the court's decision being part of Case No. 2025-05503.
Details surrounding the incident indicated that the brace was not properly secured at the time it fell. Lazo's legal team argued that this failure constituted a violation of safety regulations, specifically citing 12 NYCRR § 23-2.2(a), which outlines safety requirements for construction forms and supports.
The Ruling
The court ruled in favor of the defendants, affirming the lower court's decision to deny Lazo's motion for summary judgment on his Labor Law claim based on 12 NYCRR § 23-2.2(a). The court stated, "Plaintiff failed to plead a violation of 12 NYCRR § 23-2.2(a), and raised that Industrial Code section for the first time in his motion for summary judgment." This ruling emphasizes the importance of properly framing legal claims and adhering to procedural requirements.
The court further explained that Lazo's late introduction of the regulatory section prejudiced the defendants' ability to defend against the claim. The ruling clarified that the circumstances of the incident did not fall within the scope of the regulatory language, which applies specifically to forms and supports that are structurally safe and properly braced.
Additionally, the court granted summary judgment to Redcom CM Inc., stating that the company had only general supervisory authority over the project and did not directly control the safety practices related to the concrete work. The ruling highlighted that only employees of Glenco Contracting Group were responsible for the specific safety issues surrounding the concrete work.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for construction workers and employers in New York. It reinforces the necessity for workers to clearly articulate their claims and adhere to procedural rules when seeking legal recourse for injuries sustained on the job. By affirming the dismissal of Lazo's claims, the court has set a precedent that emphasizes the importance of timely and accurate legal pleadings.
Moreover, the decision may deter future claims that lack a solid foundation in established safety regulations. Workers and their legal representatives must be diligent in ensuring that their claims are properly framed from the outset to avoid dismissal on procedural grounds.
What's Next
As of now, it remains unclear whether Lazo will appeal the ruling to a higher court. The court filing did not indicate any pending related cases. However, the outcome of this case may influence future litigation involving Labor Law claims in New York's construction industry.
Read Next
Court rules on speeding conviction appeal in Simpson case
New York court rules against Indigo Secured High Income Note
Court upholds decision on attorney disqualification in NY case
Court limits class certification in toxic exposure case
Court rules on liability in Arita v. FDS Associates case
Mississippi Court Affirms Ruling on Workers' Compensation Case










