A New York appellate court has upheld the dismissal of a religious discrimination lawsuit filed by Cortney Lidder against her former employer, Breakthrough T1D. The court ruled that it lacked jurisdiction over the case because the impact of Lidder's termination occurred in Nevada, where she lived and worked. This decision is significant as it clarifies the jurisdictional boundaries for discrimination claims under New York State and City Human Rights Laws.

The ruling, issued on November 17, 2026, affects Lidder and similar plaintiffs who may seek to file discrimination claims in New York based on employment actions that occur outside the state. The court's decision emphasizes the importance of where the alleged discriminatory actions take place, potentially limiting the ability of out-of-state employees to seek legal recourse in New York.

Background

Cortney Lidder, formerly known as Cortney Cortez-Huth, filed a lawsuit against Breakthrough T1D, previously known as the Juvenile Diabetes Research Foundation International. Lidder alleged that her termination from the organization was based on religious discrimination, violating both New York State and New York City Human Rights Laws.

The case reached the Appellate Division after a lower court dismissed Lidder's complaint on December 12, 2025. The dismissal was based on the court's finding that it lacked subject matter jurisdiction over the claims, as the alleged discriminatory impact of her termination was felt in Nevada, where she had been living and working.

Lidder's role with Breakthrough T1D involved overseeing fundraising efforts in several states, including Nevada, Arizona, and New Mexico. She attended only one in-person event in New York, which was a training session. This limited interaction with New York was central to the court's ruling.

The Ruling

The Appellate Division unanimously affirmed the lower court's decision to dismiss the case, stating that the allegations did not establish a discriminatory impact in New York. The court noted, “The motion court properly found that it lacked subject matter jurisdiction over plaintiff's religious discrimination claims against her former employer.”

The judges emphasized that even though Lidder was paid through a New York payroll system and received operational support from the New York office, these factors were insufficient to establish jurisdiction. The court referenced prior cases to support its decision, indicating that the location of employment and the impact of termination were crucial in determining jurisdiction.

The ruling also clarified that Lidder's reliance on a previous case, Syeed v. Bloomberg L.P., was misplaced. The court pointed out that Lidder did not plead that she sought and was denied an opportunity to work in New York, which further weakened her claims.

Impact

This ruling sets a precedent regarding the jurisdictional limits of New York's Human Rights Laws. It highlights the necessity for plaintiffs to establish a clear connection between their claims and the state of New York to pursue legal action. The decision may discourage out-of-state employees from filing discrimination lawsuits in New York if their cases do not meet the jurisdictional criteria.

The ruling could have broader implications for employers and employees alike. Employers may feel more secure knowing that they are less likely to face lawsuits in New York for actions taken outside the state. Conversely, employees working remotely or in multiple states may need to consider the jurisdictional implications of their employment situations when seeking legal recourse for discrimination.

What's Next

The court's decision can potentially be appealed to a higher court, but details on whether Lidder plans to pursue further legal action were not available in the court filing. There are no related cases pending that were mentioned in the opinion.