The Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals has upheld a lower court's ruling against Norman Charles Rhodes, affirming that he owes over $641,000 in unpaid taxes. The court's decision, issued on November 20, 2026, comes after Rhodes attempted to evade taxes by using a scheme involving common-law trusts. The ruling is significant as it reinforces the IRS's authority to challenge such tax evasion strategies and clarifies the legal standards surrounding trust validity in Michigan.

Rhodes, along with his wife Jeannie Karen Parker-Rhodes and a trust named July Thirtyfirst, was the subject of a lawsuit filed by the United States in the Eastern District of Michigan. The case, identified by docket number 25-1842, arose after the IRS audited Rhodes and determined that he had failed to pay taxes on income generated by his businesses since 1997. The court's ruling not only holds Rhodes accountable for his tax liabilities but also orders the sale of his home to satisfy the debt.

Background

Norman Rhodes founded a graphic arts company, Rhodes Graphics, in 1980 and later acquired D&G Sign Company. Both businesses filed tax returns until the 1990s when Rhodes began exploring ways to reduce his tax liability. He attended presentations by Brent Johnson, who promoted the use of common-law trusts as a means to avoid taxes. Rhodes established three trusts, including one for his home, and stopped filing tax returns.

Despite the IRS's attempts to engage Rhodes during an audit, he did not cooperate. The IRS ultimately assessed his income based on bank deposits from his businesses, which Rhodes claimed were not his. After the United States sued him for unpaid taxes, the district court granted summary judgment in favor of the government, ruling that Rhodes owed over $558,000 in taxes and penalties and ordering the sale of his home.

The Ruling

The Sixth Circuit Court, led by Judge Eric E. Murphy, affirmed the district court's ruling, stating, "Any rational factfinder would conclude that Rhodes earned the income produced by his businesses." The court found that Rhodes's claims of not earning income were unsupported, as he had continued to operate his businesses and pay himself from their accounts. Furthermore, the court ruled that the trust structure Rhodes used did not meet Michigan's legal requirements for a valid trust.

Judge Murphy noted that Rhodes's failure to file tax returns since 1997 and his attempts to evade taxes through the common-law trust scheme were insufficient to absolve him of his tax liabilities. The court highlighted that the IRS's assessment had a "minimal evidentiary foundation," and Rhodes bore the burden of disproving the income attributed to him, which he failed to do.

Impact

This ruling has significant implications for taxpayers attempting to use similar tax evasion strategies. The court's decision reinforces the IRS's position against common-law trusts as a means to avoid tax obligations. It clarifies that taxpayers cannot escape their tax responsibilities through contractual arrangements that lack legal validity. This ruling may deter others from pursuing similar schemes, as it establishes a precedent for the IRS's authority to challenge and enforce tax laws.

Moreover, the court's affirmation of the district court's ruling on the invalidity of Rhodes's trust structure serves as a reminder that taxpayers must adhere to state laws when establishing trusts. The decision emphasizes the importance of having a definite beneficiary in trust arrangements, which Rhodes's trusts lacked.

What's Next

Rhodes may seek further legal recourse, including an appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court, although the likelihood of success is uncertain given the court's clear ruling. There are no related cases pending at this time, but the outcome of this case could influence future tax litigation involving similar trust structures.