In a recent ruling, the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York dismissed a claim brought by Erie Insurance Company against the Town of Venice. The court's decision, made on November 20, 2026, affects the insurance company and its insured, Frank I. Cady Trucking LLC, who sought to recover costs related to property damage and personal injuries. The ruling underscores the importance of proper legal procedures when filing claims against public entities.

The case, Erie Insurance Company of New York v. Town of Venice, was filed under docket number 737 CA 25-01301. The court's decision is significant because it clarifies the requirements for filing a notice of claim against a municipality, which is a necessary step for any tort-related actions.

In this case, Erie Insurance acted as a subrogee for Frank I. Cady Trucking LLC, which alleged that its damages were caused by the negligent operation of a vehicle by an employee of the Town of Venice. The dispute arose when Erie Insurance sought to recover amounts paid under Additional Personal Injury Protection (APIP) coverage for the damages and injuries incurred. The case reached the Appellate Division after the Supreme Court of Cayuga County initially denied the Town's motion to dismiss the complaint.

The Town of Venice, represented by Long Law, P.C., filed a motion for leave to reargue its previous motion to dismiss the case. The Supreme Court granted this motion, ultimately leading to the dismissal of the complaint against the Town. The court found that it had misapprehended the law regarding the necessity of serving a notice of claim.

The court ruled, "General Municipal Law § 50-e (1) (a) requires service of a notice of claim within 90 days after the claim arises '[i]n any case founded upon tort where a notice of claim is required by law as a condition precedent to the commencement of an action or special proceeding against a public corporation.'" This ruling emphasizes that a notice of claim is essential for any tort claims against public entities.

Furthermore, the court determined that the letters sent by Erie Insurance to an incorrect address did not fulfill the requirement of serving a notice of claim. The court noted that there was no evidence that the letters were received by the appropriate party, as required under General Municipal Law § 50-e (3) (c). The court stated, "the letter[s] fail[ed] to contain a claim of tort liability against the Town" and did not provide sufficient information for the Town to investigate the claim.

The ruling by the Appellate Division is a reminder of the procedural hurdles that claimants must navigate when pursuing claims against municipalities. It highlights the importance of adhering to legal requirements, such as timely and properly serving a notice of claim. Failure to meet these requirements can result in the dismissal of a case, as seen in this instance.

Moving forward, this decision serves as a precedent for similar cases involving claims against public entities in New York. It reinforces the necessity for claimants to ensure they follow all procedural steps to protect their rights and interests when filing lawsuits against municipalities.

As for what’s next, Erie Insurance may consider appealing the decision to a higher court, although the opinion does not specify any plans for an appeal. There are currently no related cases pending that would affect this ruling.