The New York Appellate Division has upheld a lower court's decision in a property ejectment case involving the Anita Stevens-Swan Humane Society and Ryan Harvey. The ruling, made on November 20, 2026, affects both parties as they continue to dispute property rights and responsibilities.
The case, officially titled Anita Stevens-Swan Humane Society v. Ryan Harvey, was filed under docket number 841 CA 25-01911. The court's decision means that neither party has gained a clear advantage in the ongoing legal battle.
Background
The parties in this case are the Anita Stevens-Swan Humane Society, a nonprofit organization dedicated to animal welfare, and Ryan Harvey, an individual who has been involved in a property dispute with the organization. The humane society claims rights to a property that it believes is essential for its operations, while Harvey has contested these claims.
The dispute arose when Harvey allegedly refused to vacate the property, leading the humane society to file for ejectment. Ejectment is a legal process used to remove a person from a property they are occupying without legal right. The case was initially heard in Oneida County, where the Supreme Court ruled on motions for summary judgment from both parties.
In March 2025, the Supreme Court of Oneida County, presided over by Judge Bernadette T. Clark, denied Harvey's motion for summary judgment, which sought to dismiss the humane society's claims. The court also denied the humane society's cross-motion for summary judgment, which aimed to resolve the case in its favor without a trial.
The Ruling
The Appellate Division, consisting of Justices Curran, Bannister, Greenwood, Hannah, and Skinner, reviewed the case and ultimately affirmed the lower court's order. The court ruled that the previous decisions made by Judge Clark were justified and did not require change. The ruling stated, "The order so appealed from is unanimously affirmed without costs." This means that the court found no errors in the initial ruling and that both parties would bear their own legal costs.
By affirming the lower court's decision, the Appellate Division has reinforced the idea that the case requires further examination, potentially leading to a trial to resolve the issues at hand. The court did not provide additional details on the reasoning behind its decision, indicating that the matter remains complex and unresolved.
Impact
The court's ruling has significant implications for both the Anita Stevens-Swan Humane Society and Ryan Harvey. For the humane society, the decision means that it must continue its legal battle to secure the property it claims is vital for its operations. The organization may need to prepare for a lengthy legal process that could involve a trial.
For Harvey, the ruling indicates that he must remain in a state of uncertainty regarding his rights to the property. The court's decision prevents him from gaining a quick resolution to his claims, which could impact his plans and financial situation. This case highlights the complexities of property law and the challenges that can arise when disputes occur between organizations and individuals.
What's Next
As the case moves forward, both parties may consider their options for appeal or further legal action. The Appellate Division's ruling does not prevent either party from seeking additional remedies or pursuing further litigation. Details were not available in the court filing regarding any related cases or potential future motions.
Read Next
Court vacates judgment in inmate's Eighth Amendment case
New York court upholds child maltreatment report against father
New York court grants father sole custody in family dispute
New York court dismisses appeal in parental rights case
Court modifies penalty for inmate in disciplinary case
Court rules on child neglect case involving Darcie C.










