The Louisiana Court of Appeal has upheld the conviction of Andrew Adaway for second degree murder. Adaway was found guilty by a jury for the fatal beating of Bobby Young while both were incarcerated in the Shreveport City Jail. The court's decision, rendered on November 18, 2026, confirms that Adaway's actions directly led to Young's death, which occurred 17 days after the attack.

This ruling is significant as it reinforces the legal standards surrounding murder convictions and the admissibility of evidence in criminal trials. Adaway's conviction and life sentence without the possibility of parole, probation, or suspension of sentence will remain in place following this appeal.

Background

Andrew Adaway was arrested on June 3, 2022, for trespassing at a Food Mart in Shreveport. Following his arrest, he was placed in a locked intake cell with Bobby Young, who was already in custody. Almost immediately, Adaway attacked Young, delivering at least 12 punches to his head. Young, who was unable to defend himself, fell and hit his head on the floor. He was taken to the hospital but succumbed to his injuries 17 days later.

Initially charged with second degree battery, Adaway's charges were upgraded to second degree murder after Young's death. During the trial, Adaway's defense argued that he did not intend to kill Young and that the negligence of jail staff contributed to Young's fatal injuries. The case was tried in the First Judicial District Court for the Parish of Caddo, Louisiana, under Judge Donald Edgar Hathaway, Jr.

The Ruling

The Louisiana Court of Appeal, led by Judge Ellender and joined by Judges Hunter and Marcotte, affirmed the trial court's decision. The court ruled that the trial court did not err in excluding evidence related to a civil lawsuit filed by Young's family against the Shreveport City Jail. The court stated, "The allegations contained in the Young family’s civil petition were irrelevant to the jury’s determination of Adaway’s guilt or innocence."

Adaway contended that the trial court's comments and rulings on evidence eased the state's burden of proof regarding causation and intent. However, the court found no merit in these claims, emphasizing that the evidence presented overwhelmingly supported the jury's verdict. The ruling noted that Adaway's actions were intentional and directly caused Young's death, stating, "There can be no doubt Adaway intended to inflict great bodily harm upon Young when he punched him in the head no less than 12 times in quick succession."

Impact

This ruling has implications for future criminal cases, particularly regarding the admissibility of evidence and the standards for proving intent in murder cases. It reinforces the principle that a defendant's actions can be sufficient to establish intent to inflict serious harm, even if the specific intent to kill is not demonstrated.

The decision also highlights the importance of contemporaneous objections during trial, as Adaway's failure to object to certain evidentiary rulings limited his ability to appeal those issues. This case serves as a reminder of the procedural requirements necessary to preserve issues for appellate review.

What's Next

Adaway has the option to seek further review, but the court's ruling effectively closes the door on his current appeal. There are no related cases pending that could impact this ruling. As it stands, Adaway will serve his life sentence following this conviction.