The South Carolina Court of Appeals recently affirmed the murder conviction of Terron G. Dizzley, who argued that his rights were violated due to double jeopardy and false imprisonment. The court's decision, issued on November 18, 2026, affects Dizzley, who is currently serving a thirty-five-year prison sentence, and clarifies the legal standards surrounding mistrials and retrials.
Dizzley was initially convicted of murder in a retrial after his first trial ended in a mistrial. His conviction and subsequent legal battles highlight the complexities of criminal law, particularly regarding the rights of defendants in cases involving multiple trials.
Background
The case began when a grand jury indicted Dizzley for murder. His first trial took place from August 27 to August 28, 2012. After the jury reported being deadlocked, the presiding judge issued an Allen charge, encouraging the jurors to reach a verdict. However, the jury remained unable to agree, leading the judge to declare a mistrial. The judge remarked that the jury's inability to reach a consensus was a strong indication that the prosecution had not met its burden of proof.
Following the mistrial, Dizzley was retried from March 31 to April 3, 2014, before a new judge. This time, the jury found him guilty of murder, resulting in a thirty-five-year prison sentence. Dizzley subsequently filed motions for a judgment notwithstanding the verdict and for a new trial, both of which were denied by the trial court.
In June 2014, Dizzley filed a direct appeal but later dismissed it voluntarily, intending to pursue post-conviction relief (PCR). The court granted this request, allowing him to focus on his PCR application, in which he raised multiple claims, including ineffective assistance of counsel. However, the PCR court ultimately denied his application, and the South Carolina Supreme Court dismissed his appeal for procedural reasons.
The Ruling
On October 28, 2021, Dizzley filed an emergency petition in the trial court, seeking his immediate release. This petition included claims of double jeopardy, asserting that the mistrial was declared without manifest necessity and that the judge's comments effectively amounted to a judgment of acquittal. The trial court denied this motion on April 12, 2022, stating that the mistrial was appropriate given the jury's deadlock.
The court ruled, "a review of the motion and supporting documents indicate that [Appellant's] first trial resulted in a mistrial after the jury failed to reach a unanimous verdict," affirming that jeopardy did not attach and that Dizzley's double jeopardy rights were not violated. Dizzley later sought to alter or amend this ruling, but the trial court denied that motion as well.
The Court of Appeals, in its decision, noted that Dizzley's claims regarding double jeopardy were available for appellate review following his second trial. The court emphasized that he had previously pursued a PCR petition but did not raise the double jeopardy claims there. Thus, the court concluded that Dizzley had not exhausted available remedies and could not use habeas corpus as a substitute for an appeal.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for Dizzley and others in similar situations. It clarifies that defendants cannot claim double jeopardy if they do not raise such claims in their initial appeals or post-conviction relief applications. The court's decision reinforces the importance of timely and thorough legal action in criminal cases.
Furthermore, the ruling emphasizes the court's position on the necessity of mistrials. It indicates that a judge's remarks during a trial do not automatically equate to a judgment of acquittal, particularly in cases where jurors are deadlocked. This decision may serve as a reference point for future cases involving similar legal questions.
What's Next
Dizzley has the option to appeal this ruling to the South Carolina Supreme Court, although the court's decision has already affirmed the lower court's ruling. Details were not available in the court filing regarding any related cases pending.
Read Next
Court affirms convictions in South Carolina drug trafficking case
Court upholds conviction of James Jeffrey Boatwright
Court upholds murder conviction of Fanotti N. Neal
Oregon court affirms conviction and sentence of Stephens
Oregon Court Affirms Conviction of Ricki Scott Collin
Oregon court upholds conviction in sexual abuse case










