The Ohio Court of Claims granted summary judgment to the University of Toledo Medical Center in a medical malpractice lawsuit filed by Jennifer Gard and her husband, Alva Gard. The court ruled that the plaintiffs' claims were time-barred, meaning they were filed after the legal deadline for such actions. This decision affects the Gards, who alleged that medical negligence led to unnecessary surgeries for Jennifer Gard.
The case, Gard v. University of Toledo Medical Center, was filed under case number 2025-00899JD. The plaintiffs claimed that Dr. Nicole Dominiak, an employee of the medical center, misdiagnosed Jennifer Gard’s condition in March 2023. The Gards argued that this misdiagnosis resulted in a series of painful and unnecessary surgical procedures, causing Jennifer Gard both physical and emotional distress.
In their lawsuit, the Gards sought damages for medical negligence, vicarious liability, and loss of consortium. They contended that the medical center should be held responsible for Dr. Dominiak's alleged mistake, which was later corrected by a review from the Cleveland Clinic. The court's ruling is significant as it highlights the importance of adhering to legal timelines in medical malpractice claims.
Background and Procedural History
The Gards initially filed a medical malpractice complaint against the University of Toledo Medical Center on August 13, 2025. However, this case was dismissed without prejudice on October 22, 2025, due to a failure to comply with a court order. Following this dismissal, the Gards refiled their lawsuit on October 30, 2025.
In their complaint, the Gards alleged that Dr. Dominiak incorrectly diagnosed Jennifer Gard with microcystic adnexal carcinoma (MAC) instead of basal cell carcinoma (BCC). They claimed that the misdiagnosis led to unnecessary surgeries that left Jennifer Gard disfigured and embarrassed. The Gards argued that if the correct diagnosis had been made, a simpler Mohs procedure could have been performed, avoiding the extensive surgeries and associated damages.
Defendant University of Toledo Medical Center responded to the Gards' complaint, admitting some facts but denying liability. On September 1, 2026, the medical center filed a motion for summary judgment, asserting that the Gards' claims were time-barred under Ohio law. The court reviewed the evidence and arguments presented by both parties before reaching its decision.
The Ruling
The court ruled in favor of the University of Toledo Medical Center, granting the summary judgment motion. Judge Lisa L. Sadler stated, "Because, after the evidence is construed most strongly in plaintiffs’ favor, plaintiffs’ claims are time-barred and defendant is therefore, as a matter of law, entitled to a judgment in its favor." This ruling indicated that the court found the Gards' claims did not meet the legal requirements for timely filing.
According to the court, the statute of limitations for medical malpractice claims in Ohio is one year from the date the cause of action accrues. The court determined that the Gards were aware of their injury on August 6, 2024, during a telehealth visit with a Cleveland Clinic provider, when they were informed about the misdiagnosis. Since the Gards did not file their lawsuit until August 13, 2025, the court concluded that their claims were filed after the expiration of the statute of limitations.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for medical malpractice claims in Ohio. It reinforces the importance of timely filing lawsuits and adhering to statutory deadlines. The decision also clarifies that the discovery rule, which allows for the tolling of the statute of limitations until a plaintiff is aware of their injury, does not apply in this case because the Gards were deemed to have sufficient knowledge of their injury by August 2024.
The outcome of this case may discourage future claims that are not filed within the appropriate time frame, as the court emphasized the necessity of adhering to legal deadlines. It serves as a reminder for individuals pursuing medical malpractice claims to be vigilant about the timing of their actions to avoid being barred from seeking justice.
What's Next
The Gards may consider appealing the court's decision, but details were not available in the court filing regarding any plans for an appeal. There are currently no related cases pending that would affect this ruling.
Read Next
Ohio Court upholds sentencing in Gallagher vehicular case
Ohio court affirms domestic violence conviction of McCall
Ohio Court dismisses Copeland's petition against Judge Michael
Court dismisses personal injury claim in Stelmach v. Simone case
Court affirms ruling in slip-and-fall case against supermarket
Court rules in favor of plaintiffs in rear-end collision case










