The Ohio Court of Claims ruled in favor of the Ohio State Highway Patrol (OSHP) in a case involving a motor vehicle collision between a civilian and a state trooper. The court granted summary judgment to the OSHP, stating that the trooper was responding to an emergency call at the time of the accident. This ruling affects the plaintiff, Megan K. Deel, who sought damages for injuries sustained in the collision.

The case, Deel v. Ohio State Highway Patrol, was filed under docket number 2025-00872JD. The incident occurred on May 4, 2022, when Deel collided with Trooper Crystal Jones' patrol car in Madison County. The court's decision is significant as it highlights the legal protections afforded to law enforcement officers while performing their duties.

Background

Megan K. Deel is the plaintiff in this case, seeking damages from the Ohio State Highway Patrol following a car accident. The collision involved Trooper Crystal Jones, who was driving a marked patrol car at the time. The dispute centers around whether Trooper Jones was negligent and whether the OSHP could be held liable for the incident.

The case reached the Ohio Court of Claims after Deel filed a motion for partial summary judgment on the issue of liability, while the OSHP filed a motion for summary judgment asserting immunity under the public duty doctrine and the emergency call doctrine. The court reviewed both motions without an oral hearing, considering the evidence and arguments presented by both parties.

The Ruling

The court ruled in favor of the Ohio State Highway Patrol, granting its motion for summary judgment and denying Deel's motion for partial summary judgment. Judge Lisa L. Sadler stated, "Even when construing the evidence most strongly in plaintiff’s favor, reasonable minds can only conclude that Trooper Jones did not engage in willful or wanton misconduct." This ruling underscores the court's determination that Trooper Jones was acting within the scope of her duties when the accident occurred.

The court found that Trooper Jones was responding to an emergency call at the time of the collision, which provided her with immunity from liability. The judge noted, "Defendant is entitled to immunity as a matter of law" based on the circumstances surrounding the incident. The court's decision emphasized that the trooper's actions did not constitute willful or wanton misconduct, which is necessary to overcome the immunity provided to law enforcement officers in such situations.

Impact

This ruling has significant implications for both law enforcement and civilians. It reinforces the legal protections that officers have while responding to emergencies, which can limit the ability of individuals to seek damages in similar cases. The decision may set a precedent for future cases involving police officers and their conduct during emergency responses.

The ruling also highlights the importance of the emergency call doctrine in determining liability. As the court noted, Trooper Jones was acting in her professional capacity when she attempted to pursue a speeding vehicle, thus justifying her actions at the time of the accident. This case may influence how similar cases are litigated in the future, particularly in terms of the standards for evaluating police conduct during emergencies.

What's Next

As of now, it is unclear whether Deel plans to appeal the court's decision. The ruling effectively concludes this case in favor of the Ohio State Highway Patrol, but Deel may have the option to seek further legal recourse. There are no indications of related cases pending that would impact this ruling.