A California court has dismissed an appeal filed by Amber Aye in a child custody dispute with her ex-husband, Dion Aye. The court ruled that the appeal was taken from nonappealable orders and lacked jurisdiction. This decision affects the custody arrangement for their two children and highlights the complexities of family law in California.

The case, known as In re the Marriage of Dion Aye and Amber Aye, was filed under docket number F090709. The court's ruling comes after a series of custody orders and disputes that began following the couple's divorce in December 2023. The court's decision is significant as it sets a precedent regarding the appealability of temporary custody orders.

Background

Dion and Amber Aye were married but divorced in December 2023. Following their divorce, a custody arrangement was established, granting Dion primary physical custody of their two children during the school year, with Amber receiving visitation every other weekend. This arrangement was agreed upon by both parties and was not appealed at that time.

In October 2024, a domestic violence restraining order (DVRO) was issued against Dion in Placer County. This development led to further complications in the custody arrangement. In February 2025, Dion filed an ex parte request for a temporary emergency order, seeking sole legal custody and supervised visitation for Amber. He claimed that during a recent visit, Amber made false accusations about abuse. The court granted a temporary emergency order, which was later extended as the case continued.

The Ruling

The California Court of Appeal ruled that Amber's appeal was not valid. The court stated, "The existence of an appealable order or judgment is a jurisdictional prerequisite to an appeal, and so if the order or judgment is not appealable, the appeal must be dismissed." The court emphasized that the orders Amber sought to appeal were temporary and not final, thus falling outside the scope of appealable orders.

Judges on the panel included Justice Snauffer, Acting Presiding Justice Franson, and Justice Harrell. They noted that Amber's appeal was filed in a timely manner but ultimately determined that the orders she was appealing from were not appealable. The court explained that temporary custody orders do not meet the criteria for appealability under California law.

Impact

This ruling has significant implications for Amber and Dion Aye as it reinforces the idea that temporary custody orders are not subject to appeal. The court's decision clarifies that appeals can only be made from final orders or judgments, which can affect how custody disputes are handled in the future. It also highlights the importance of understanding the legal framework surrounding custody arrangements and the limitations of appealing temporary orders.

The ruling may discourage other parties in similar situations from pursuing appeals based on temporary custody orders, as it sets a clear precedent that such appeals are unlikely to succeed. This could lead to more stability in custody arrangements, as parties may be less inclined to challenge temporary orders that are not deemed appealable.

What's Next

Amber Aye's options for further legal action are limited due to the dismissal of her appeal. It is unclear whether she will seek to modify the existing custody arrangements through the lower court. There may also be related cases pending, particularly concerning the domestic violence restraining order and its implications for custody. Details were not available in the court filing.