The United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit affirmed the dismissal of a lawsuit filed by Justin Mattera, a special education math teacher against the Westhampton Beach School District. The court ruled that Mattera's reassignment did not constitute retaliation under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) or the First Amendment. This decision, made on November 17, 2026, affects Mattera and potentially other educators in similar situations.
Justin Mattera worked for the Westhampton Beach School District from 2009 until the events leading to this lawsuit. He taught integrated math classes, which included both learning disabled and non-learning disabled students. In the 2021-22 academic year, the school district introduced a new non-integrated math class aimed at students struggling academically. Mattera expressed concerns that this class would lead to grade inflation and undermine the rights of learning disabled students. After voicing these concerns, he was reassigned to teach a non-Regents geometry class and four resource room classes.
In response to his reassignment, Mattera filed a lawsuit claiming that the school district retaliated against him for advocating for learning disabled students. He alleged violations of the ADA, the Rehabilitation Act, and the First Amendment. Additionally, he claimed that the reassignment interfered with his advocacy efforts. The Westhampton Beach School District moved to dismiss the case, and the district court granted this motion.
The case was brought to the Second Circuit Court of Appeals, where the judges reviewed the district court's decision. The court noted that to prove retaliation under the ADA and the Rehabilitation Act, Mattera needed to show that he experienced an adverse employment action. The judges explained that an action is considered adverse if it is materially adverse, meaning it would dissuade a reasonable worker from making a discrimination claim.
The court found that Mattera's reassignment did not meet this standard. Although he was moved from teaching Regents math to a non-Regents math class, the court stated, "Even construing his complaint liberally, he does not allege any harm beyond receiving a less desirable assignment than he had previously received." The judges emphasized that without demonstrating material harm, Mattera's claims could not be substantiated.
Furthermore, the court addressed Mattera's First Amendment claims. The judges ruled that his complaints about the new class fell under the category of speech made pursuant to his official duties as a public employee. They stated, "Because Mattera is expected to engage in such speech in the course of carrying out his job, the First Amendment does not prevent his public employer from regulating such speech." Therefore, his claims of retaliation based on First Amendment rights were also dismissed.
The court did not address Mattera's claim of interference under the ADA, as he did not challenge the district court's decision on this point during his appeal. The judges concluded that Mattera's remaining arguments were without merit and affirmed the district court's judgment.
This ruling has significant implications for educators and public employees. It clarifies the standards for retaliation claims under the ADA and the First Amendment, particularly regarding what constitutes an adverse employment action. The decision may discourage similar claims by employees who feel they have been retaliated against for voicing concerns about workplace practices.
Moving forward, Mattera's case sets a precedent for how courts may interpret retaliation claims within educational settings. It highlights the importance of demonstrating material harm in retaliation cases and reinforces the idea that public employees’ speech related to their official duties may not be protected under the First Amendment.
As for what's next, Mattera may seek to appeal this decision to a higher court, but details regarding any potential appeal were not available in the court filing. There are no related cases pending at this time.
Read Next
Court upholds convictions in health care fraud case
Second Circuit affirms firearm possession sentence for Saunders
Court affirms sentence for Raheem Maldonado's violations
Vermont court denies motion to dismiss in workplace case
Vermont court upholds small claims judgment against Feinberg
Pennsylvania court affirms child support ruling in Burda case










