The Second Circuit Court of Appeals has denied a request for an en banc rehearing in the case of Miller v. McDonald, docket number 24-681. This case involves a challenge to New York's vaccine mandate that affects Amish schools, raising significant questions about religious freedom and parental rights.

The plaintiffs in this case, which include Joseph Miller and three Amish schools, argue that New York's law violates their First Amendment rights by imposing fines for noncompliance with vaccination requirements. The law, which was amended in 2019 to eliminate religious exemptions, has led to fines of $118,000 per day for the schools, prompting this legal battle.

The decision to deny the rehearing was made on November 17, 2026, following a previous ruling in June that upheld the state's vaccine mandate. The case has implications for how states can enforce public health laws while respecting religious beliefs, particularly for communities like the Amish that have distinct cultural practices.

Background

The plaintiffs in Miller v. McDonald are Joseph Miller, Ezra Wengerd, Jonas Smucker, and three schools: Dygert Road School, Pleasant View School, and Shady Lane School. They are challenging the New York Public Health Law (PHL) 2164, which mandates vaccinations for children attending school. The law previously allowed for religious exemptions, but this was repealed in 2019 amid concerns over vaccination rates following measles outbreaks.

The Amish community, which traditionally opposes vaccinations based on their religious beliefs, has been particularly affected by this law. The New York Department of Health audited the schools and found them noncompliant, resulting in substantial fines. The plaintiffs filed a lawsuit claiming that the law violates their rights under the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment.

The case made its way through the courts, with the district court dismissing the plaintiffs' claims. The plaintiffs then appealed to the Second Circuit, which upheld the law, stating it was neutral and generally applicable. However, the Supreme Court later intervened, citing a recent ruling in Mahmoud v. Taylor, which established that laws significantly interfering with religious practices must undergo strict scrutiny.

The Ruling

In the dissenting opinions, Circuit Judges Michael H. Park, Joseph F. Bianco, and Steven J. Menashi argued that the law does indeed impose a significant burden on the Amish community's religious practices. They criticized the panel for misinterpreting the Supreme Court's guidance in Mahmoud, stating that the New York law effectively forces Amish parents to choose between their religious beliefs and the education of their children.

The dissenting opinion noted, "New York’s law directly burdens the rights of parents to direct the religious upbringing of their children," highlighting the severe implications for the Amish community.

Impact

The denial of rehearing in Miller v. McDonald sets a significant precedent regarding the balance between public health mandates and religious freedoms. The ruling reinforces the ability of states to impose vaccination requirements, especially in the context of public health crises, while raising concerns about the treatment of religious exemptions.

This case particularly impacts the Amish community in New York, as their educational practices and religious beliefs are closely intertwined. The fines imposed could lead to the closure of Amish schools, fundamentally altering how the community educates its children. The dissenting judges warned that the ruling could have dire consequences for the Amish way of life, as it undermines their ability to maintain their cultural and religious practices.

What’s Next