In a recent ruling, the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit affirmed a lower court's decision to grant summary judgment in favor of the law firm Napoli Shkolnik, PLLC, and its individual defendants in a discrimination case. The court's decision, filed on November 17, 2026, affects Selma Moy, the plaintiff, who alleged discrimination, a hostile work environment, and retaliation against her former employer. This ruling underscores the importance of adhering to procedural rules in legal cases.
Selma Moy, a former employee of Napoli Shkolnik, filed a lawsuit against the firm and several individuals, including Paul Napoli and Marie Napoli. She claimed that she faced discrimination and a hostile work environment, which led to retaliation against her. The case was initially heard in the Southern District of New York, where the district court allowed some of Moy's claims to proceed to discovery while dismissing others. The court set a Civil Case Management Plan and Scheduling Order that outlined specific deadlines for the discovery process.
Despite the established deadlines, Moy did not take any significant steps to advance her case until the last day of the discovery period. On January 31, 2025, she requested a sixty-day extension to complete her fact discovery. The district court denied this request, citing Moy's lack of diligence and the untimely nature of her request. The court noted that she had not provided any initial disclosures, served written discovery requests, or responded to the defendants' requests during the discovery period.
Following this, the defendants moved for summary judgment, arguing that Moy had no admissible evidence to support her claims due to her failure to engage in the discovery process. In her opposition to the motion, Moy submitted various documents and witness declarations, but the district court declined to consider this evidence because it was not disclosed during the fact discovery period.
The district court ultimately granted the defendants' motion for summary judgment for two main reasons. First, it concluded that Moy lacked admissible evidence to support her claims, as she had not provided any timely disclosures or information during the discovery period. The court stated, "there is no timely-disclosed record evidence to support [Moy’s] claims." Additionally, the district court found that Moy had failed to prosecute her case, which also justified the summary judgment under Rule 41(b).
In her appeal, Moy argued that the district court abused its discretion by dismissing her case for failure to prosecute. However, the Second Circuit found that while a failure to prosecute may justify dismissal under Rule 41(b), it was not a valid basis for granting summary judgment under Rule 56. The appellate court agreed that the district court's decision to grant summary judgment was appropriate because Moy did not have any admissible evidence to support her claims.
The Second Circuit stated, "Without any evidence properly before the district court to support her claims, Moy cannot carry her burden." The court emphasized that Moy had forfeited any challenge to the exclusion of her untimely evidence and that her failure to provide timely disclosures severely weakened her case. The ruling highlights the importance of adhering to procedural rules and deadlines in legal proceedings.
This decision has significant implications for future cases involving discrimination claims. It reinforces the necessity for plaintiffs to actively participate in the discovery process and to comply with court-imposed deadlines. Failure to do so can lead to the dismissal of their claims, as seen in Moy's case.
Looking ahead, Moy's options for further legal action are limited. The court's ruling affirms the lower court's decision, making it unlikely that this case will be appealed further. There are no indications of related cases pending in this matter. As a result, this ruling serves as a cautionary tale for individuals pursuing discrimination claims in the future.
Read Next
Court upholds convictions in health care fraud case
Second Circuit affirms firearm possession sentence for Saunders
Court affirms sentence for Raheem Maldonado's violations
Court affirms ruling in sexual harassment case against OSU
California court reverses summary judgment in job case
California court upholds Abortion Accessibility Act in ruling










