A Delaware court has ruled against Gregory Freiberg's request for attorney fees following his unsuccessful challenge to his removal from the board of directors of Xonar Technology Inc. The ruling, issued on November 18, 2026, in the Court of Chancery, highlights the complexities of corporate governance and the standards for awarding attorney fees in such cases.

The case, Freiberg v. Xonar Technology Inc., C.A. No. 2026-0093-KSJM, stems from a dispute over Freiberg's removal from the board, which he argued was improper due to alleged inaccuracies in the company’s capitalization table. This ruling is significant as it clarifies the application of the corporate benefit doctrine in Delaware law, particularly regarding attorney fees in corporate governance disputes.

Background

Gregory Freiberg was a member of the board of directors at Xonar Technology Inc. In January 2026, stockholders of the company executed written consents to remove him from the board. Freiberg contested this removal, claiming that the written consents were invalid because they were based on an inaccurate representation of his stock ownership in the company.

To challenge his removal, Freiberg filed a summary proceeding under Delaware law, specifically 8 Del. C. § 225. This legal action allowed him to seek a determination regarding the validity of the stockholder consents that led to his removal. Xonar Technology, in response, obtained additional written consents from two stockholders, which played a critical role in the court's analysis of the case.

During the proceedings, Xonar stipulated to accept Freiberg's version of the capitalization table for the purposes of the dispute, with two exceptions: whether the McFadden Consents should count towards his removal and the methodology for calculating Freiberg’s share ownership. Ultimately, the court ruled that Freiberg failed to prove that the McFadden Consents were invalid, which meant he could not prevail in his challenge.

The Ruling

In the court's opinion, Chancellor Kathaleen St. Jude McCormick denied Freiberg's motion for attorney fees and expenses. The court ruled that under Delaware law, each party typically bears its own legal costs unless an exception applies, such as when a party confers a corporate benefit through their legal actions.

“Freiberg is not entitled to fees under this standard,” the court stated. “The equitable nature of the remedy means that even if a litigant technically satisfies the requirements, the court may still decline to award fees and expenses.”

The court emphasized that Freiberg's lawsuit did not conclusively prove the inaccuracies he claimed about the capitalization table or the validity of the stockholder consents. The court noted that Freiberg's arguments overstated the findings of the earlier opinion, which did not reach conclusions about the validity of the capitalization table.

Furthermore, the court pointed out that the primary motivation behind Freiberg's legal action appeared to be his personal interest in retaining his board seat rather than a broader corporate benefit. The ruling referenced a similar case, Keyser v. Curtis, where the court denied attorney fees because the plaintiffs were primarily seeking to benefit themselves rather than the corporation.

Impact

The ruling in Freiberg v. Xonar Technology Inc. has important implications for corporate governance and the awarding of attorney fees in Delaware. It reinforces the principle that attorney fees are not automatically granted even when a litigant's action may have some merit or result in a corporate benefit.

This decision serves as a reminder that parties challenging corporate actions must clearly demonstrate that their legal efforts have conferred a tangible benefit to the corporation, rather than serving primarily personal interests. The ruling may deter similar future claims where the motivation is primarily personal, as it underscores the necessity of aligning legal actions with the broader interests of the corporation.

What's Next

Details were not available in the court filing regarding whether Freiberg plans to appeal this decision. There are no known related cases pending that would directly affect this ruling.