The Louisiana Court of Appeal ruled on November 20, 2026, to dismiss an appeal by Arch Insurance Company concerning asset seizures related to a personal injury judgment. This decision affects Arch Insurance and the parties involved in the original case, including Jacob Tramble, who is acting as curator for Sherri Tramble. The court deemed the appeal moot after determining that the underlying judgment had been fully satisfied.
This case originated from a motor vehicle accident involving Joshua Briscoe, the driver of another vehicle, and was brought to court by Jacob Tramble on behalf of Sherri Tramble. The initial lawsuit was filed in the Twenty-Seventh Judicial District Court for St. Landry Parish. Following a trial, the court awarded a significant judgment of over $219 million against Briscoe, his employer Linetec Service, LLC, and Arch Insurance, which was the insurer for Linetec. Both Briscoe and Linetec appealed the judgment, which was later amended by the Third Circuit Court of Appeal to approximately $40 million in general damages and over $41 million in future medical expenses.
While the appeal was ongoing, Tramble filed a petition in the Nineteenth Judicial District Court to enforce the judgment, claiming that Arch had not taken a suspensive appeal and that the judgment had not been paid. The court granted Tramble's request, making the judgment executory and allowing for asset seizures from Arch's business partners. Arch subsequently filed a motion for a preliminary injunction to stop these seizures, arguing that it had fully paid its policy limits and that the trial court's actions violated constitutional rights.
On December 17, 2025, the trial court denied Arch's motion for a preliminary injunction, prompting Arch to appeal. However, during the appeal process, Tramble filed a motion to dismiss the appeal as moot, stating that Arch had satisfied the judgment in full by May 8, 2026. Tramble argued that since the judgment was fully paid, there were no longer any garnishments to be enjoined, rendering Arch's appeal moot.
The court agreed with Tramble's argument, stating, "An issue is moot when a judgment or decree on that issue has been deprived of practical significance or made abstract or purely academic." The court noted that since the underlying money judgment had been satisfied, there was no longer a need for injunctive relief. The court emphasized that the appeal was moot because the act Arch sought to prevent had already occurred.
In its ruling, the court dismissed Arch's appeal and ordered that all costs associated with the appeal be assessed to Arch Insurance Company. This ruling underscores the principle that appeals regarding injunctive relief become moot if the situation changes during the appeal process, eliminating the need for judicial intervention.
This decision has implications for Arch Insurance and similar cases involving asset seizures and enforcement of judgments. It highlights the importance of timely responses in legal proceedings and the potential for appeals to become moot if the underlying issues are resolved before the appeal is heard.
Moving forward, Arch Insurance has the option to seek further legal recourse, although the current appeal has been dismissed. The court's ruling does not preclude Arch from pursuing other claims related to the seizure of its assets or the enforcement of the judgment, but it does close the door on this particular appeal.
Read Next
Louisiana Court Denies Appeal in Murder Case of Adrian Dunn
Court reverses trial ruling on prescription in vehicle accident case
Court denies rehearing in Ratliff v. GoAuto Insurance case
Nevada Supreme Court affirms dismissal in forfeiture case
Court affirms dismissal of student loan reporting case
Court dismisses appeal by federal inmate Afeez Alao










