In a recent ruling, the Hawaii Intermediate Court of Appeals addressed a significant employment dispute involving Adam O. Mays and Pacific Permanente Group LLC, along with Hawaii Permanente Medical Group, Inc. The court's decision, filed under docket number CAAP-25-0000160, affirmed the lower court's summary judgment in favor of the defendants, marking a critical point in employment law regarding whistleblower protections and contract breaches.
The case centers around Mays, a physician extender, who claimed that his employer breached his employment contract and violated the Hawaii Whistleblowers' Protection Act (HWPA). The court's ruling is crucial as it clarifies the boundaries of employee protections under the HWPA and the responsibilities of employers regarding employment contracts.
Background
Adam O. Mays was employed by Pacific Permanente Group as a Physician Extender in Orthopedics. His employment was governed by a Practitioner Employment Agreement that outlined his responsibilities and the terms of his employment. In 2020, Mays faced challenges with his supervisors regarding his work schedule, which led to a series of meetings and communications that ultimately resulted in his taking an unauthorized leave of absence.
During this period, Mays sent an email to several high-ranking officials within the organization, expressing his concerns about his treatment and the implications of a forced change in his work schedule. He described the situation as hostile and indicated that he felt compelled to take a leave of absence due to the circumstances. Following his leave, Mays's employment was terminated, prompting him to file a lawsuit against Pacific Permanente and Hawaii Permanente in July 2021.
The Ruling
The Hawaii Intermediate Court of Appeals ruled that the lower court's summary judgment was appropriate on both claims presented by Mays. The court found that Mays had breached his employment contract by taking an unauthorized leave of absence, stating, "Mays admitted taking an unauthorized leave of absence. Having breached the Agreement himself, he cannot maintain a claim for breach of contract against Pacific Permanente."
Furthermore, the court ruled that Mays's claims under the HWPA were also unfounded. The court explained that Mays's email did not constitute a report of a violation of any law, rule, or regulation, stating, "No reasonable jury could interpret the email as a 'report' of 'a violation or a suspected violation of . . . [a] law, rule, ordinance, or regulation.'" The judges involved in the ruling were Chief Judge Karen T. Nakasone and Associate Judges Keith K. Hiraoka and Clyde J. Wadsworth.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for both employees and employers in Hawaii. For employees, it underscores the importance of understanding the terms of their employment agreements and the consequences of unauthorized actions, such as taking leave without approval. The court's decision also clarifies the limitations of whistleblower protections under the HWPA, emphasizing that not all complaints or grievances will qualify for protection under the law.
For employers, the ruling reinforces the need for clear communication regarding employment expectations and the consequences of breaching contractual obligations. It also highlights the importance of documenting employee performance and any issues that arise during employment, as these records can be crucial in legal disputes.
What's Next
The case has been remanded to the lower court to determine the amount of attorney fees that Pacific Permanente and Hawaii Permanente are entitled to recover. Mays's options for appeal are limited, as the court has affirmed the lower court's ruling on both claims. Details were not available in the court filing regarding any related cases pending.
Read Next
Hawaii Supreme Court dismisses Geffeney's mandamus petition
Hawaii Court Vacates Driving Charges Against Kalavi
Hawaii court rules on appeal in DUI case of Sarah Baggs
Nevada Supreme Court dismisses appeal for jurisdictional issues
Nevada Supreme Court Dismisses Appeal in Child Protection Case
Nevada Supreme Court affirms dismissal in forfeiture case










