A recent ruling by the Ohio Court of Appeals has denied a great-grandfather's request for visitation rights with his two great-granddaughters, Emma and Olivia. The court's decision, made on November 20, 2026, emphasized the importance of the children's safety and well-being, which was a primary concern in the case.
The case, Waymeyer v. Waymeyer (Docket No. CA2026-01-004), involved Michael T. Waymeyer, the children's father, and Sarah Waymeyer, their mother, along with Donald Knecht, the great-grandfather seeking companionship rights. The court's ruling underscores the complexities of custody and visitation rights in family law, particularly in situations involving allegations of abuse.
The dispute began in 2021 when Sarah Waymeyer sought a civil protection order against Michael Waymeyer. Although the order did not name the children as protected parties, it prohibited Michael from contacting them. Following their separation, Sarah began a relationship with another man, Charles Smith, which led to further legal complications. Michael later obtained a protection order against Smith, citing concerns for the children's safety.
As the custody battle unfolded, the Clermont County Court of Common Pleas designated Sarah as the children's temporary custodian. However, after a series of hearings, the court ultimately determined that Michael would be the children's residential parent, granting him supervised visitation with Sarah. The court's findings were based on concerns regarding the children's safety and the credibility of the parties involved.
In January 2024, Donald Knecht, the children's great-grandfather, filed a motion for visitation rights. He later moved to intervene in the divorce case between Michael and Sarah, which was granted. A guardian ad litem (GAL) was appointed to represent the children's interests during the proceedings.
During a hearing held in May 2025, the court heard testimony from both Michael and Knecht, along with the GAL's report. The GAL expressed concerns about Knecht's understanding of the abuse the children had suffered and recommended limited visitation. However, the magistrate ultimately denied Knecht's request for companionship time, citing the children's well-being as the primary factor.
The magistrate's decision was later upheld by the domestic relations court, which emphasized the need to give special weight to the wishes of the children's fit parent, Michael. The court noted that there were no allegations of parental unfitness against him, and the evidence indicated that the children were thriving under his care.
In its ruling, the Ohio Court of Appeals affirmed the lower court's decision, stating, "The magistrate and the domestic relations court properly balanced the factors under R.C. 3109.051(D) and gave Father the requisite 'special weight' as a fit parent." The court acknowledged the importance of the grandparent-grandchild relationship but emphasized that the burden of proof lies with the grandparent to demonstrate that visitation would be in the child's best interest.
The court's decision signifies a strong stance on prioritizing children's safety and well-being in custody and visitation disputes. It illustrates the legal framework that governs such cases, particularly the special weight given to a fit parent's wishes in determining visitation rights.
Moving forward, this ruling may have implications for similar cases involving grandparents seeking visitation rights. It reinforces the notion that while maintaining family connections is important, the primary consideration must always be the children's best interests.
As for Knecht, he may consider appealing the decision, but the court's ruling sets a significant precedent regarding the balance of parental rights and grandparent visitation requests. Details were not available in the court filing regarding any potential next steps for Knecht.
Read Next
Ohio Court affirms prison sentence for Angela S. Nichols
Ohio Court upholds summary judgment in police injury case
Ohio Court upholds dismissal of firearm charges against teen
Nevada Supreme Court dismisses appeal for jurisdictional issues
Nevada Supreme Court Dismisses Appeal in Child Protection Case
Nevada Supreme Court affirms dismissal in forfeiture case










